preview

Analysis Of Sin By Agnes Repplier

Satisfactory Essays

Would you rather betray your dear friend or betray a “country” that has shaped your lifestyle through its culture and traditions? It is a very hard decision to make, but a famous writer once said that if the time came when he had to make a choice, he hoped to have the courage to betray his country rather than his friend. I agree with this opinion because of both my life experiences and evidence throughout the text “Sin” by Agnes Repplier. In the story Agnes, the main character, betrayed her country which in context was her mother, her religion, and Madam Bouron in order to keep her friend safe. The reasons I believe that betraying a country over a friend is better is the fact that it proves true loyalness to the friend and demonstrates the betrayer’s desire to protect the friend’s feelings over anything else in life.

The first reason why betraying a friend over a country is beneficial is the act of proving true loyalness to that particular friend. In the story, Agnes showed true loyalness by betraying Madame Bouron in order to show how dedicated she was to her friend over her mother and the church. An example proving this is when Madame Rayburn said, “You have borne false witness against your neighbor”. This quote proves that Agnes did betray her friend by lying to her which she did with acknowledgement of the consequences which include committing a sin of lying to Lily and betraying Madam Bouron which was against her religion. Despite this, she did in fact remain loyal and this is shown when Madam Bouron says, “You have been false to your mother … but you have been true to your friend”. So even though Agnes did was false to her country which in the context of the quote was her mother, she remained faithful and devoted to keeping her friend in safe comfort. Similar to Agnes, I have made choices where I lied to my parents but it was only to protect my dear friend from having his feelings hurt and his reputation diminished. Therefore, one of the reasons that justify the action of betraying oneś country over a friend is to openly show how trustworthy and passionate one is about their friend.

In addition, protecting a friend's feelings and emotions makes lying to a country worth it. Specifically in the text,

Get Access