Family and Sacrifice
“I swore never to be silent whenever and wherever human beings endure suffering and humiliation. We must take sides. Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim. Silence encourages the tormentor, never the tormented,” – Elie Wiesel, author of Night, made this important statement during his Nobel Peace Prize acceptance speech in Oslo of 1986. As my friends Audrey Porter, Jordan Rogers, and I entered into Mrs. Bergeski’s room, I had many questions about what ‘aspect’ of the Holocaust, the movie, Life is Beautiful, was going to portray. “What’s going to happen to these people? Will any of their family members die? Will anyone survive this horror?” I had asked myself. When the movie began, the first few minutes were
…show more content…
As most Holocaust stories progress, the central figure ends up expelled from their native lands. This film was no exception as both Guido and Gisoue end up being deported to a concentration camp. For me, I felt heartbroken as since I have read many articles and books about or relating to the Holocaust, I knew that they would be put under immense suffering. Both Audrey and I had exchanged looks as we both had prior knowledge about this stage of Holocaust deportation. But despite the German deportation of Jews, Dora (a non-Jew), decided to be voluntarily transported to a concentration camp due to her immense love for Guido and her son. During Guido’s time at the camp, there are many times that Gisoue could have been exposed to the many forms of discrimination and the choices between life and death. However, Guido is able to successfully prevent his son from knowing that any day could be their last, ultimately protecting Gisoue from the extreme and unbelievable hate of their era. Guido can be seen protecting his son through his quick thinking while serving German children food, hiding him in a metal cage/box, and going far enough to tell Gisoue that the whole concentration camp situation was a ‘competition’ or ‘game’ to win a tank. For me, that takes very serious skill, dedication, and courage, and so I admire that.
At the end of the movie, a myriad of different situations and conflicts begin to emerge. The biggest
He was finally free, no joy filled his heart but abandonment was drowning it. How dangerous is indifference to humankind as it pertains to suffering and the need for conscience understanding when people are faced with unjust behaviors? Elie Wiesel is an award winning author and novelist who has endured and survived hardships. One of the darkest times in history, a massacre of over six million Jews, the Holocaust and Hitler himself. After the Holocaust he went on and wrote the internationally acclaimed memoir “Night,” in which he spoke out against persecution and injustice across the world. In the compassionate yet pleading speech, ¨Perils of Indifference,¨ Elie Wiesel analyzes the injustices that himself and others endured during the twentieth century, as well as the hellish acts of the Holocaust through effective rhetorical choices.
As the most famous Holocaust theme author, the Nobel Peace Prize Winner, Elie Wiesel’s painful memoir novel, Night, records his personal nightmares as a young Jew during the World War II and impacts today’s world profoundly. The terrible living condition in the ghetto, the numb of the prisoned Jews to send the little body of Jewish children into the cremation chimney, the diminishing faith of Elie to God, the little hope of surviving and so on, too many such horrible scenes mingle in every reader’s mind and meanwhile arise a lot of questions. Aren’t those German soldier human beings? Why the SS and Gestapo have not any mercy to those normal elegant Jews, including those lovely young girls and cute children? Why most of the Aryan people just stand by during that time but not shelter the Jews? How can the people in a democratic German make their collective decisions to support the dictator Hitler? What’s wrong with that generation of people living in that land? Can we prevent such genocide happen again in today’s world?
When people look at two extremely different stories such as Night and Life is Beautiful, they would not expect there to be many similarities. However, these two devastating tales are more alike than suspected. Both Night and Life is Beautiful may be two accounts of the holocaust, but that does not mean that they bring the same thing to the table. They both may include a somewhat similar father-son relationship, yet they still aren’t that same. Night, a tragic memoir of Eliezer Wiesel, and Life is Beautiful, a humorous and still somewhat depressing movie of Guido and his family, have numerous similarities as well as drastic differences between them.
When learning about the Holocaust, most are deprived of being able to understand the emotions, thoughts, and experiences of the millions of Jews; however, Elie Wiesel gives this opportunity through the telling of his personal experience. After ten years of silence, Elie Wiesel recounts his personal experiences of the Holocaust and retells the horrific details of the events he witnessed in his honest, eye-opening memoir Night. Taken at a young age, Elie Wiesel is transported to Auschwitz; at this concentration camp, Wiesel is separated from his mother and younger sister, whom he would never see again. During his years in the concentration camp, Wiesel and his father worked long exhausting hours every day. After a forty-two mile trip from Auschwitz to Gleiwitz in the snow and bitter cold, Elie Wiesel watches the slow death of his father by malnutrition and a harsh beating from the Nazis. Three months later American forces liberate the camp, freeing Wiesel. One of the most important memoirs one can read and a true inspiration, Night deserves to be read by everyone.
The Holocaust is widely known as one of the most horrendous and disturbing events in history that the world has seen; over six million lives were lost, in fact the total number of deceased during the Holocaust has never been determined. The footage of concentration camps and gas chambers left the world in utter shock, but photos and retellings of the events cannot compare to being a victim of the Holocaust and living through the horror that the rest of the world regarded in the safety of their homes. Elie Wiesel recognized the indifference that the
In the world during the time of the Holocaust, there was indifference towards the suffering of millions of Jews. When individuals reflect about the Holocaust, the majority of the time the responsibility of the terrible events is placed upon the perpetrators. However, bystanders and witnesses indirectly affected the victims of the Holocaust as well. The silence of these people played one of the largest roles in the Holocaust, they influenced it by avoiding any type of involvement and by becoming blinded towards the suffering of others. In his Academy Award acceptance speech, Elie Wiesel says, “the opposite of love is not hate, it’s indifference”. This exert from his speech reveals the importance
Whether it's having fun while barely surviving, or hiding in a secret annex, living through the holocaust is tough. In the film Life is Beautiful by Roberto Benigni, the main character, Guido, was a Jew at the horrific time of the holocaust. In the play The Diary of Anne Frank by Frances Goodrich and Albert Hackett, Anne’s family, the Franks, are forced to go into hiding after the Holocaust starts. Both of these stories are about the Holocaust. However, the Franks knew about the Holocaust, and decided to take actions into their own hands. They went into hiding and created a diversion in their house to throw off the police. Their good friend, Miep, has a secret annex in their workplace and let the Franks stay in the annex. In contrast, Guido
How does Benigni convey the idea of creativity using coincidence in his film Life is Beautiful?
Life is Beautiful, directed by Italian director Roberto Benigni, released in 1997, is a film about love, war and death. Set just before and during WWII, the main character, Guido falls in love with the woman of his dreams, they have a child but they get separated by the horrors of the war. Guido and his little son strive to get reunited with his wife but their internment in a Nazi concentration camp halts him from doing so. Nevertheless, he slyly keeps in contact with his wife so she knows they are safe and well.
The 1997, film “It Is Beautiful” is a perfect combination of humor, imagination, and reality. Writers, Vincenzo Cerami and Roberto Benigni, wrote the film as a comical aspect of the Holocaust, though Holocaust was not comical at all. It had a very positive vibe in the beginning because it was about love and romance and even when it turned darker the vibe continued. One of the writers, Benigni, also played the part as Guido the main character who was comical and full of life. The main woman role, Dora, was played by Nicoletta Draschi who came from a rich family. Nicoletta played a strong woman who would go to great lengths for her family. The director, Roberto Benigni, portrayal of the concentration camp is a realist way but keeping it light
The atrocities of the Holocaust, along with the suffering of its victims, are spoken of in literary texts and shown in films. Can the Holocaust actually be represented ethically, in a way that honors the horrific suffering of the victims, and in a real sense, by either of these forms of narrative representations, especially film? Critics argue both sides of this question; some stating that the movie, Schindler’s List, trivializes the Holocaust; whereas, others defend the film. This paper will look at both sides of this argument; the positive side of Richard Kearney and the negative side of Claude Lanzmann.
The overarching theme throughout Life is Beautiful is the importance of family, this is backed up through a range of other themes, the two major ones being sacrifice and innocence. These two themes are intertwined throughout the film as Guido takes many sacrifices and risks to not only protect his son’s life but his innocence as well. Sacrifice is shown in many forms throughout the film, from seemingly innocent gestures such as Dora throwing away her past life to marry Guido to heart wrenching acts of love and compassion between Guido and his son, Joshua. One of these moments take place during the climax of the film, when the concentration camp that Guido and his family have been imprisoned in is being evacuated in the wake of the oncoming allied forces. Guido is caught sneaking around the concentration camp trying to find his
It was one of the worst human rights disasters ever to face our planet. Tens of millions of people, told they were not worth their own lives, were rounded up and marched off to camps where death was their almost certain fate. The Holocaust perpetrated by the Nazi regime during World War II has become the centerpiece for countless movies, books, essays, tv shows, and plays, each and every one shedding it’s own light on how it has affected different people and their families. Aryeh Lev Stollman and Art Speigelman are just two of the countless writers that have brought us emotional stories of families affected by the Holocaust. Stollman’s piece, Die Grosse Liebe, from his 2003 short story collection entitled The Dialogues of Time and Entropy, portrays a young boy who, after his father’s death, begins to learn more and more about his sometimes mysterious and self-hidden mother who has, for as long as young Joseph has known, been exiled in her own home where she speaks little and with almost no emotion whatsoever. Speigelman’s piece, an excerpt from his serialized book Maus, is a memoir in graphic form in which Speigelman himself asks his father to recount his days before, during, and shortly after the war. Both pieces provide an in depth look into the way the narrators learn about themselves, their family history, and the world in general.
Even after seventy years, the Holocaust still proves to be the most horrific and haunting tragedy in human history. No one can ever forget the horrors, especially the lucky survivors of the tragedy whose memories are now the constant reminder of the pain, and terror inflicted upon them. Determined to never let the same thing happen again, many Holocaust survivors decided to transform their nightmares into heart wrenching account of hope, fear, and sorrow. Elie Wiesel is one of those brave men, and women who agree to share the dark time of his life in his heartbreaking, and utterly real memoir Night. In Night, Elie used his raw, and emotional experience to force the readers to reexamine the prominent roles that fear,
The film Life is Beautiful takes place during the Holocaust in the 1930s. It is about a man named Guido Orefice who falls in love with a woman named Dora. During the first half of the movie, Guido does everything he can to make Dora fall in love with him. A short time elapses in the movie and we see Guido and Dora married and with a child named Giosuè. Guido and Giosuè are sent to a concentration camp where Giosuè's father does his best to turn the concentration camp situation into a game.