preview

Argument Analysis: D4 Appeals To Emotion

Decent Essays

D4 - Appeals to Emotion Emotion is the premise for this discussion. We see in chapter four of our text that emotion is one way of handling an argument. Moreover, the text gives different outlines for the aspects used in emotion. The stand out fallacies include ad populum, ad baculum, and ad misericordiam. The simplified versions of the fallacies include the ad populum or popular argument. Second is the ad baculum or threatening argument. Finally, the last ad misericordiam which equates to the pity argument. In order to make a case for this artistic works the least feasible case would be made by using ad baculum. With ad baculum some form of fear factor is expected. The text give two options used with ad baculum “threat or appeal to force” (Walton, 2008, p. 116). With the two options not very kind or …show more content…

Lyrics in the work is not as pronounced and in some cases are unintelligible. This style may be what the artist is going for, and that is one was to express the art. However, if the lyrics contained something of relevance it may be missed by the unconverted. The argument style suitable for this discussion is challenging. One key point that makes the choice simplified is the fact that one may not know the feelings of the population when faced with this music. That fact means that ruling out using ad populum since we cannot gauge the expressions on the faces of the rest of the class when listening to the track. This leaves the opportunity to use the ad misericordiam if any to make an argument. This would be something along the lines of expressing the end result of listening to the entire track. When one listens to the track, White Chalk by PJ Harvey, the songs express a sullen felling of woe that changes subtly through the stanzas until the final and bitter sounding end (Harvey, 2013). This work evokes a feeling of despair and darkness that brings down the day and leads to negative thoughts seeping

Get Access