preview

Beatty Samuelson Essay

Better Essays

7. Bluffing can be ethical, depending on the circumstances and how it is employed. In fact, Beatty Samuelson, in Essentials of Business Law, points out the “Kantian evasion or plater”, which serves as the basis for deceiving someone in an ethical way. She describes it as “a truthful statement that is nonetheless misleading” (36). For instance, Kant’s example of a murderer coming to our door -asking for someone who is in our own home and who he wants to kill – illustrates an instance when answering questions fully could lead to terrible consequences (36). In that case, Samuelson argues, telling the truth and pointing the killer to the victim would be very costly, so it is better to employ Kant’s evasion principle and reply with a truthful, but misleading statement. Immanuel Kant, according to Samuelson, …show more content…

Although gender discrimination currently receives intermediate Fourteenth Amendment Scrutiny, they should receive strict scrutiny. As Samuelson points out, like in the case of race, “A government action interfering with a fundamental right receives strict scrutiny and will likely be declared void” (127). Gender discrimination, just like race discrimination, should also be considered an interference with a fundamental right and, therefore, receive strict scrutiny. The repercussions of the severe problem of gender discrimination in American society can be seen in the gender pay gap in our country. In fact, according to the Institute for Women’s Policy Research, “In 2014, female full-time workers made only 79 cents for every dollar earned by men, a gender wage gap of 21 percent. Women, on average, earn less than men in virtually every single occupation for which there is sufficient earnings data for both men and women to calculate an earnings ratio.” The fact that women are discriminated on the basis of gender in the workplace and paid less than men is sufficient to argue that gender discrimination should be treated with the same scrutiny as race

Get Access