preview

Because Of Winn Dixie Analysis

Decent Essays

Julianne Marquez
A. Foster
LIT 465 11:15 T/TH
03 December 2015
Because of Winn-Dixie by Kate DiCamillo: Comparing the Novel to the Film After reading Because of Winn-Dixie, a novel by Kate DiCamillo, I really enjoyed following the story of a little girl name India Opal Buloni and her scruffy dog, Winn-Dixie, and the delightful friends she encounters while trying to get used to living in a new town. When I heard that there was a movie adapted from the novel, I was very skeptical of how great the movie’s adaptation of the novel will would compare to the actual novel itself. After watching the film, Because of Winn-Dixie, directed by Wayne Wang, 2005, I was quite pleased at how great the producers were able to follow the unique story line and …show more content…

At the end of the movie, they were looking for Winn-Dixie, and they could not find him, so everyone began singing a hymn, and Winn Dixie began howling outside the front door. Everyone became excited because he came back. They begin to sing songs again (Because of Winn-Dixie 2005). In the book, the story ended with Gloria, Franny, and Opal singing, Sweetie Pie hearing somebody sneezing, and them discovering that Winn-Dixie is hiding under Otis’ bed. Furthermore, all the important scenes in which the main characters were involved in the film were designed the same way as in the book. Couple examples are how Otis is singing to the animals, Gloria Dump and her “ghosts” created out of alcohol bottles hanging from her tree, and Winn-Dixie running after the mouse in the church. These examples show how the movie does stay true to the novel in some …show more content…

Right away, I quickly noticed that Winn-Dixie smiled throughout the movie instead of sneezing all the time like in the book. In the novel, it reads the following, “He smiled at me. He did that thing again, where he pulled back his lips and showed me his teeth. He smiled so big that it made him sneeze” (DiCamillo 12). This is the only difference that I did not like because I believe, in a sense, that it took away the personality of Winn-Dixie’s character portrayed in the book. Another key difference was when Winn-Dixie was almost captured by the dog pound in the film, which this never depicted in the novel. Two other examples are Winn-Dixie never running away, or the fact that the trailer park manager disliked him. Two very notable differences in the movie not portrayed in the book were Mr. Alfred’s role. Alfred was one of the characters who were not in the book along with the town police officer. Mr. Alfred is the owner of the trailer park where Opal and the preacher, Opal’s father, live. In the book, Alfred is mentioned just once, the part where he lets Opal be an “exception” as far a living in a trailer park only meant for adults. However, in the movie, he becomes a “wicked” character, making the Opal’s father to pay rent because of having Winn-Dixie and saying that he will send the dog to the pound. But, in the end, he ends

Get Access