preview

Canadian Indian Residential Schools : Material Cultures Of North America

Better Essays

Canadian Indian Residential Schools:
Truth Be Told

Katy McNabb
HIS755 - Material Cultures of North America
October 30th, 2014

The history of Canadian Indian Residential schools has attracted a considerable amount of attention in Canada in recent years. Most people do not want to revisit the pain and suffering that countless Aboriginal peoples endured, and the loss of such beautiful cultures. Since the introduction of the Canadian Indian Residential school system in 1857, through the Gradual Civilization Act, there has been concern whether the outcome of the schools would leave a positive or negative mark on the Aboriginal peoples of Canada. Although there are many recorded cases of abuse and ill treatment; within the …show more content…

This was evident in a interview with David Ashdown, the Executive Archdeacon and now bishop of Keewatin1. David was a supervisor at the Stringer Hall Residential school in Invuvik for four years, and recounts the positive experiences; “The students were very good, very bright. I was proud to be a part of it. I had a sense that these young people would be the future leadership of the Northwest Territories. And they were. One became prime minister; another a deputy minister, several became chiefs, mayors or business leaders.”2 David is quick to defend the school system in response to complaints. He talks freely about a conversation with a friend and a school administrator: “But look at all the good that came out of it. Look at yourself, for example.’ David’s student replied: ‘Yeah, I learned to survive there’”3. David, however, was a Christian Canadian, and may have had a slight biased on how he viewed the success of the children. David believes that the children “flourished” while his student replies that they merely “survived”. When the depletion of buffalo populations, an invaluable resource for many Aboriginal peoples, occurred in the 1870’s, it destroyed the economy of the Plains Indians and Métis, and it then seemed necessary to help them convert from hunting to agriculture as a way of survival.4 Tom Flanagan, a professor of political science at the University of Calgary; author of First Nations? Second Thoughts questions whether or not the Aboriginal

Get Access