preview

Canal Zone Gender

Good Essays

Race, Class, and Gender in the Panama Canal Zone
It is impossible to begin to understand the dynamics of the Panama Canal Zone without looking at the intersectionality of race, class, and gender within the Zone. Racism, classism, and sexism were seen in many day to day interactions between Panamanians, United Statesians*, and West Indians in the Zone. These prejudices were seen first through the power dynamics between Panama and the United States, and the citizens of each. Donoghue describes the Zone as the result of a “Mephistophelian deal with the United States” (9). In this description, the United States acted as Mephistopheles, a devil from Faust by Goethe, which in turn used its power to exploit Panama, demonstrating from the beginning …show more content…

Donoghue explains that the canal “provided jobs and economic opportunities for the Panamanians,” which gives United Statesians power (9). The fact that the Zone provided jobs and helped stimulate the economy can be construed in a way that says to Panamanians “we as the United States brought you these jobs, therefore you must subject yourselves to us.” The United States held a lot of economic power, which was demonstrated through the fact that the “Latin and West Indian Panamanians [working in the Zone] were never fairly compensated for their labor compared to white U.S. workers” (10). Anyone who wasn’t white was paid “lower wages in silver” compared to the white workers from the United States who were paid “in gold” (26). This practice caused a deliberate wage gap between white and non white workers, which transitioned into segregation based on whether a worker was paid in gold or silver-- similar to the segregation seen in the U.S. south at the time. Simply the idea of paying workers in the same currency was a “threat to U.S. supremacy” and caused this practice to continue until the 1970s (62). The United States asserted its power over minority workers through the unfair wages, keeping them in a perpetual lower class. The effects of this blatant discrimination based on race are seen today, as Panama still suffers “from the second worst maldistribution of income in the hemisphere” …show more content…

A Panamanian stated that the border between the Zone and Panama was so “irregular not even educated persons [knew] exactly where it [ran]” (40-41). This border indicated the place where Panama stopped and the United States began, which in turn caused the exclusion of Panamanians from this land even though it was once Panama. Military bases were more easily distinguishable, since they were often “demarcated by barbed-wire fences and guarded gates,” and were were very exclusive regarding who was allowed to enter (30). This illustrates the mindset that United Statesians were better and more worthy of being in the Zone than Panamanians. The uneven power dynamic between police and Panamanians was still in play when it came to the border. Oftentimes, police in the Zone “apprehended poorer Panamanians of color who crossed the border” when they were visiting friends or family (43). Police could “‘deport’ Panamanians from a part of their own country” which further demonstrates the power that white, United Statesian men had over their Panamanian counterparts

Get Access