Catherine Sloper's Self-realization in Henry James' Washington Square
In his essay, "Washington Square: A Study in the Growth of an Inner Self," James W. Gargano argues convincingly that the Henry James's novel, Washington Square, revolves around the emotional, psychological, and spiritual development of Catherine Sloper. With one small exception, Gargano makes his case so persuasively that it seems hard to believe that there could be any other view of Catherine and her role in the book. Yet, Gargano asserts that James scholars before him have persistently focused elsewhere leaving Catherine to be categorized much the same way her father characterizes her as dull and listless (Gargano 355, 357).
Gargano rightly shifts the critical
…show more content…
Evidence of James' regard for his heroine's development can be found throughout the second half of the novel. After Catherine informs her father that she and Townsend plan to marry and her father responds by suggesting a postponement and a European tour, James' narrator tells us that:
her father's displeasure . . . cost the girl . . .a great deal of deep welling sorrow-sorrow of the purest and most generous kind. . . but for the first time . . . .there was a spark of anger in her grief." (James 140)
Gargano correctly praises James for "undertak[ing] the difficult art of making the undemonstrative, psychic unfolding of his heroine arresting and interesting" (Gargano 357).
Gargano acknowledges that many readers find Catherine "stupid" for not recognizing Townsend's heinous deceit, but answers skeptics with the notion that Catherine is demonstrating a kind of spiritual wonder. Offering the counter example of Mrs. Penniman's irresponsible tendency to propagate romantic fantasy, Gargano asserts his claim that Catherine's thinking is a kind of sacred expression of "faith and poetry" (Gargano 359).
Gargano's essay authoritatively argues that it is James's intention to show the transcendent nature of emotional, psychological and spiritual growth by focusing on the subtle development of Catherine Sloper, but one part of his discussion lacks insight. Gargano seems to
"The beast my father roared especially ugly roars today. I have never seem to please him, although it is true I never try. "35 This talks about how terrible her father (Lord Rollo) is and how Catherine never pleases him. This is because Catherine and her father do not like each other. "Now my father, the toad,conspires to sell me like a cheese to some lack-wit seeking a wife. "5 This talks about how Catherine's father would sell her like cheese so he could become rich with her marriage. Catherine's father does not care about her happiness only his, so he does whatever he pleases. Soon she learned she cannot escape her life but make the best she can. One thing that on old lady told that she realizes now is "why are you not catherin?" Now she knows she can't hide from herself but stand up to her life.and he she would be In a lot of
The involvement of a family member with the previously misjudged character directly causes each heroine’s fallout of sorts with her future husband, who will henceforth be referred to as the hero. Catherine’s brother James becomes involved with Isabella before she is known to be such a determined flirt, but when she all but abandons him for Captain Tilney, it becomes known to General Tilney that Catherine’s family is not as rich as formerly supposed, and this results in
[2] In the second chapter, James introduces his own voice. He begins by describing his mother's strange traits, which are both likable and embarrassing, and explains her difference from his friends parents and other adults. James first reveals one of the reasons for writing this memoir, which is to find explanations for his mother's behavior in the events that went on in her life.
Jacobs ' short sexual orientation change through cross-dressing, trailed by her long "withdraw" into aggregate physical disguise, is telling confirmation of how contrastingly a subjugated man and an oppressed woman reacted to the difficulties of their lives as slaves and additionally autobiographers.
With this statement, Jacobs specified her purpose for writing and her intended audience. This insight gives readersan understanding of why she chose to include what she did in her story as well as why she chose to exclude other details. Although this work is presented as a narrative of
Catherine's pathetic ideal of a "picturesque" rendezvous is also the majority mentality at the time. Her realization of the cruel truth is but a glimpse of the futile art of war and
When Catherine resides in Thrushcross Grange, her coarse demeanor is heavily augmented by the values of the upper class. Catherine’s return from a five weeks stay at Thrushcross Grange renders “her manners much improved” and her appearance as a “very dignified person” (Bronte,37). Catherine proves to be a proper, civil woman, when on the Grange, picking up on the well-mannered tendencies of Edgar and
Whereas Frederic is passionate about the love of his life, even declaring Catherine as his religion, Catherine never truly commits to the idea of marriage, stalwartly defending her independence. Henry views a formal marriage as a necessary action to solidify his relationship with Catherine, although she believes that they are already personally married. Catherine claims that “there’s no way to be married except by church or state” (Hemingway 115). Catherine is unreligious, so her refusal to married by state is justified. However, her refusal to be married by state showcases her true intentions. After Henry continues to pester her with the idea of marriage, her attitude towards him turns hostile, as she accuses Henry of being jealous of her past marriage with another man. This dramatic change displays Catherine’s willingness to challenge obstacles, such as Henry, that are a threat to her autonomy.
Catherine is so wrapped up in her fictional world of reading that she becomes ignorant of her real life issues with Henry Tilney, for whom she has been love-struck since their introduction. She entertains herself with wild imaginings about his life and family. Catherine's imaginings foreshadow her eager desire for mischief as Austen's story develops. Catherine is endowed with a vivid imagination, but she has not yet learned to use it in concert with her perception, especially in understanding the interactions between people.
Soon after her own arrival in Bath, Catherine is followed by her brother James and Isabella’s brother John Thorpe. At the initial meeting with the boys, Catherine is mistaken on two different points, still being ignorant in her perceptions of other people. Although slightly thrown off by John’s manners, Catherine is unable to formulate her own negative opinion of him, too affected by the opinions of Isabella and James, and “her judgment was further brought off by Isabella’s assuring her…that John thought her the most charming girl in the world” (Austen 48). For Catherine, it is easier and more natural to accept the opinions of someone like Isabella, a mentor figure. Also, in the same scene, Catherine makes the assumption that her brother James has journeyed “so far on purpose to see me” (49). Catherine hastily jumps to this false conclusion, not having the experience to detect James’ continuous questions and compliments of Isabella as a sign of his true motives for coming to town: to visit the “prettiest girl in Bath” (49).
James’ novella centers around a young governess who is in charge of watching her employer’s kids at an estate in Bly. The governess’ social standing and desire to keep her job reveal the instability of jobs for women in this era. Her employer, the uncle of Miles and Flora, is a typical wealthy
She berated herself for her misjudgements and for being blinded by appearance to Wickham's untrustworthiness, which should have been evident in the discrepancy between his words and actions. She was "absolutely ashamed" of herself, and attained self-knowledge -- "Till this moment I never truly knew myself." She faced up to the unpalatable truth about herself, and determined to change. Her courage and strength are commendable. This is in contrast to, most strikingly, Mr. Collins, who completely lacks the capacity for reflection and self-awareness. The reader laughs at his self-importance and ridiculously obsequious, sycophantic manner.
Jane Austen’s Northanger Abbey is a novel that features vibrant character development but the biggest development is that which occurs in Catherine Morland. Catherine’s character nearly develops in all components of her being and she is able to evolve from the unorthodox “heroine” that she is initially described as. In the novel, Catherine starts out as an incredibly naïve and inexperienced girl who confuses all facets of the real world as the plot in a Gothic novel. Catherine develops as a character through her social interactions with those around her as it helps her gain experience with how to correctly perceive the world. With her newly gained experience of her surroundings, Catherine develops and is able to see the real world through a social lens rather than her own subjective lens or that of a Gothic lens.
Now he has made her look like a fool, which causes her to be indifferent to him for the remainder of their acquaintance. "If I could not be persuaded into doing what I thought wrong, I never will be tricked into it." So when asked again to take a ride with John, Catherine responds "If I am wrong, I am doing what I believe to be right." The sternness in her ability to make the right choices for herself is now solidified. She no longer needs to pacify others wants or requests. Through experience, Catherine is growing out of her innocence and naivety.
The narrator is unknown to the readers but describes Catherine’s, and other characters inner thoughts, that would otherwise be reserved to them. Although it is Catherine that is made the main focus, “Catherine’s feelings, as she got into the carriage, were in a very unsettled state; divided between regret for the loss of one great pleasure, and the hope of soon enjoying another”, her narrative representation is sympathetic and pleasant but the third-person structure also allows for Catherine’s nature to be presented without confusing the