preview

Character Analysis Of The Play 'Nothing But The Truth'

Decent Essays

It is hard to identify the real victim and culprit in the play, “Nothing But The Truth by AVI.” The play is about a teacher-student relationship that turns into a national headline where each side used alternate facts for personal benefit. Publicly, the conflict is heard from Philip's perspective. While the situation gets out of hand, none of the mess would have occurred if not instigated by the student, Philip Malloy.

Throughout the story, Philip is discourteous and tells several lies. For example, Miss Narwin states, “I don’t know who that is, but you heard Dr. Doane request silence.” Philip then says, ‘’I’m just humming.’’ This demonstrates how Philip is disobedient to his teacher. Not only is that disrespectful to Miss Narwin, but also the country and Dr. Doane who had called for silence. He is given five chances to stop humming before he was sent to the principal's office. Philip mislead the reporter by stating that he was singing to be patriotic. Prior to these occurrences, he had received a poor grade from Miss Narwin which prevented him from running on the school track team. This motivated his unruly behavior. Philip is being deceptive as he was really humming to get on Miss Narwin’s nerves. Towards the ending of the play, he admitted to the fact that he had never known the wording to the national anthem, meaning that he couldn’t have been singing it in the first place. Philip is dishonest when he proclaimed that the sole reasoning behind his suspension was because of Miss Narwin. In reality, Miss Narwin was against his suspension and removal from her classes. Deceitfully, he claimed that no one respected Miss Narwin. He said that to put her in a negative light but really there were many people who admired her. A group of students even made a petition to get Philip to admit he is wrong. These are only a few examples of the many ways Philip was disrespectful and dishonest.

Philip Malloy blames Miss Narwin for almost everything that occurred in the play. He wants her to look substandard because of the poor grade he was given that makes him unable to participate on the track team. In the end, he only made a fool of himself. Philip Malloy states, ‘’Bull,’’ and ‘’It’s all her fault.’’ This shows an

Get Access