preview

Comparing Lentricchia And Richardson's The Road Not Taken

Decent Essays

The poem “The Road Not Taken” has been read and interpreted by many different people. To some the poem can be seen as just a walk through woods, but to to others it is something much more than a taking a walk in the woods. Two people who have stated their opinions about the poem are Frank Lentricchia and Mark Richardson. They both have very different views and thoughts about the poem. Meanwhile, neither of them see “The Road Not Taken” as just a walk in the woods. In the articles they wrote, they talk about what they think the poem is about. Both Lentricchia and Richardson pull out pieces from the poem and explain their thoughts and opinions. Lentricchia believes the poem shows self reliance, Richardson views the poem as “step-careless”, …show more content…

He says that the poem very generously shows and expresses a theme of self reliance and brings you in with a “story of selfhood”. Lentricchia also mentions choices a number of times throughout his article. One instance is when he says that the poem is irrational because how do you decide between two identical things? Next is when he says turning point decisions help to make and get a person to where they are today. Lentricchia also believes that in life after you make another choice, you just continue to make more choices. However, he asks how the choice is made about which road to take when it is “rationally grounded on the word Difference” . Both roads are described “about the same”, so how is a choice made? In the meantime, Lentricchia’s article it talks about how Lentricchia says the poem is a analogical landscape poem. This means the is a poem about landscape, but it is really about an analogy to life. He believes nature gives us life lessons, and that life is a path and you can make changes to …show more content…

He feels like there is contradiction in the poem with the speaker's use of different tenses in several of the stanzas. He explains the poem “step-careless” because he feels like the choice that is made is somewhat careless. He said you don’t know where or what the path will bring you to. Richardson also uses “Youthful step carelessness” when describing Frost’s poem. He relates it to when you are young you make silly choices, and as you get older it will continue. In addition he says we can only understand our actions as choices. Unlike Lentricchia, Richardson says the paths we take unfold themselves as we go, and we realize our destination only when we arrive at it. Like Lentricchia, he talks about choices and how they affect our lives. For example, he talked about how once you make a choice, only afterward you will see things about the choice made. Richardson says Frost makes the poem Indecisive and decisions feel the same. Richardson states that he disagrees with Frank Lentricchia’s idea that “our life shaping choices are irrational, that we are fundamentally out of control”. Richardson says he doesn’t believe Frost argues that we are out of control and would not say so on

Get Access