preview

Comparing The Novel, Cain By Jose Saramago And Gilead By Marilynne Robinson

Decent Essays

The novels, Cain by José Saramago and Gilead by Marilynne Robinson, both present different perspectives of God and truth. Through Cain, a reader can gain a skeptical perception of God and ultimately, question the importance of religion. On an alternative side, while Gilead does not directly offer commentary to God and religion, it is the source of its characters’ strength, especially with Robinson’s character Ames. Either way, God and religion has a profound impact on Cain and Ames’ lives that not only expresses their relationship with religion but how God as an entity influences their life path. Saramago’s Cain spends most of the novel bitter towards God for cursing him. From Cain and the Narrator’s point-of-view, one can conclude that …show more content…

It is clear that Cain’s initial interaction with God was indeed a negative one but it created an outlet for Cain to question truth and to prove why religion’s truth is incorrect.
With the story of Job, “That doesn’t seem very fair of the lord…a good and upright man, and very religious too, he has committed no crime, and yet, for no reason, he is about to be punished with the loss of all his money and possessions,” Cain questions why Job will be punished as severely as he was when Job followed the ideal pious path (Saramago, 122-123). In this instance, Cain is taking a protective role as well as a critical one when it comes to God’s convoluted motivations, “The lord and satan made a wager, but this man job isn’t to know he is the object of that gambler’s agreement” (Saramago, 122). Possibly, Cain is able to relate to the citizens God tampered with since Cain felt he was not at fault for killing Abel, but rather, God was for not stopping him or giving him such a miserable life that led him to kill his younger brother. This idea that a misfortune, Job losing everything he worked for, is contradicted in Robinson’s novel, Gilead since Ames’ mother saw bad luck as a blessing, “That was a day’s work lost for her, not to mention the setting hens and the fryers. She

Get Access