Comparing US Democratic Republic, Roman Republic, and Athenian Democracy Governments

The Ancient Greeks were the first to put the power of a nation in the hands of the average citizen, they created the idea of the democratic government, practiced as a direct democracy. Voting, political assembly, and official citizenship are all concepts that can be traced back to Classical Grecian ideas .The Romans developed the concept of the representative democracy .This was best

-The Roman Republic people had a lot less power than the Athenian Democracy, But, it was supported by practices and principles. Rome could not have a direct democracy like Athens because it was so much larger.

Greece and Rome had a large influence in law since our government was based on the ideas from Ancient Greek and Rome. Greece is our birthplace of democracy because they had a systematic set of political theories and ideas. Their main political unit was city-state - some were monarchies, oligarchies, democracies, or a form of republic. Across the board, Greece used a Direct Democracy. Rome was ruled by a monarchy that expanded greatly during their republican period which lasted until Cesar became emperor.

3. Athenian Democracy: The Greek city-state, Athens, had a very distinct form of government in which

Athens started out as a monarchy, but they finally reached democracy. They have a government consisted of 6,000 people, They was all adult males. They voted on issues in Athens. To pass a law they had to be majority vote. We use direct democracy, we have a representative democracy in which the citizens democratically vote on who should make the decisions in the country.

To begin with, both of their ways that they chose the officials were similar but also differed. The Athenian Government and the Roman Republic both had the citizens of each side choose the officials, but they both had a difference in limitations on how they chose the officials. In Athens, the citizens would vote for the officials, but the people who were official citizens were the ones who were 18 or over, born in Athens, and had to be males. This means that outsiders, slaves, or women could not vote because they were not considered citizens. Additionally, the Athenian Government system for voting was organized with citizens by the name of demes or demos; who belonged to tribes and where combined with others of the same area to make a larger group, which in turn were combined to form ten tribes. (Gill, thoughtco 2017). In contrast, citizens of Rome had to be over 15 years old, male slaves could also vote if they were granted freedom, the women were considered citizens but had no voting rights. The

During my research I have learned the ancient Athenians pursued a government where all citizens would determine how the state was run. While being troubled by the tyrannical rule of a monarchy government, the newly found country American went to seek the same preparation. However Ancient Athens was a big example of a direct democracy, allowing every citizen to vote on just about every decision made in government, and all officials were decided by random. On the other hand, America is a republic, in which citizens elect officials to represent them, and the representatives do the majority of lawmaking and

Two main types are the democracy of modern day canada and old day Athens. Athenian democracy was more effective but Canadian democracy was more fair. Here’s the evidence: How where politicians elected, who can vote, and how long can political members serve. In Canadian democracy everyone can vote as long as you have met the requirements.

The Ancient Greeks had the first known democracy which is the founding basis for our government in the United States. Athenian democracy was developed around the fifth century B.C. in the polis

Classical Athens and Han China had their own kind of government with different regulations that were very much alike. The Athenians had a democratic government that they believed to be original

In comparing Athenian and American democracy, they are very different however some aspects are the same. The similarities include citizens were allowed to vote for their leader(s). However, the definition of a citizen is completely different now that it was then. A citizen back then was a male landowner in Athens, on the other hand, citizens now days are people that are born within the country or have parents

The Roman lives were based on the Twelve Tables, which were their written laws enforced by the government. The Twelve Tables were stable for over a millennium until the fall of the Roman Empire in 476 A.D. The Romans were able to keep control through fair legal rights basically saying any crime was intolerable, but could be solved in a court case to determine the fate of the criminal. The Romans were half democratic and gave the people some voice by selecting representatives. This ruling helped decimate any crime and prevent murder. Although there are many positives to this ruling, innocent newborns with a deformity were ruthlessly killed. (Doc. 6)

Have you ever thought that the U.S. government is easily comparable to the Roman's version of government? Maybe that's because the U.S. government is roughly parallel with the Ancient Roman Government. The Romans did not have a constitution, like us Americans, but their division of executive, legislative, and judicial branches is similar. The Roman government served as a template for the American government. As you read further, you will see how the governmental structures, with detail, are similar by first making points on the American style contrasted with the Roman style of government.

The next governmental institution, which represented the democratic element of the Roman Republic, are the Assemblies. These Assemblies were theoretically made up of all adult male Romans (the only exception is that they had to be present at the meetings). Their primary functions were the annual elections of consuls, approving or rejecting laws, and deciding issues of war and peace. One great flaw of this body was that the wealthier citizens voted first and thereby had a great influence on how the rest of the Assembly voted.

Roman government is the origin for all of our current government system. The Romans has three branches of government: the legislative, the executive, and the judicial. The executive had two councils that decided on pretty much every affair within the empire. In the legislative branch was a senate, which advised the executive branch. Lastly in the judicial they had a Supreme Court. Also there was a written law consisting of twelve tablets that gave allowed the citizens to know their rights. As one can tell, the Roman system of government is much like the one currently residing in the United States of America.