Referee report for the article
Regulatory Techniques in Consumer Protection: A Critique of European Consumer Contract Law
By Bar-Gill and Ben-Shahar
Brief Summary
The article mainly talks about the four methods which are widely used as the consumer protection techniques in European Contract Law. By individually discussing every technique in law aspect as well as the evaluation of the author, this article lets the readers know the content in a very clear format. There are introduction and conclusion at the beginning and the end of the paper which also provides the logical thinking of the author and made it much easier for the readers to get the idea of the whole paper.
These four categories for consumer protection techniques in European
…show more content…
It is clear from the title and also goes deeply in each aspect of the argument.
With this purpose, the two authors illustrate their criticism by analysing the four main techniques according to the current situation. Overall, the article gives the appropriate contents about the topic that the author trying to discuss. As shown in the body of this article that the writers introduce and explain each technique with the scope of the law and then make an individual part of discussion. Make the reader easily grasp the point of the writer.
As for the goal of the article, there are no specific words or sentences related to that, however, it is much easier to analyse the significance and importance of the paper, which give rise to the attention of protecting consumer’s rights. According to the article, the four main consumer protection techniques applied in European contract law are not practically useful for consumers, in that sense, this article is meaningful for not only legislator, but the ordinary buyer in everyday life to call for the promotion of the legal provision and enhance people’s awareness of protecting their own rights when doing consumption. In my opinion, this goal of the paper is significant to the nowadays developing business
The particular focus of this essay is on how terms are implied. This is central because the courts intervene and impose implied terms when they believe that in addition to the terms the parties have expressly agreed on, other terms must be implied into the contract. Gillies argued that the courts have become more interventionist in protecting the rights of contracting parties thereby encroaching upon the notion of freedom of contract. The doctrine of freedom of contract is a prevailing philosophy which upholds the idea that parties to a contract should be at liberty to agree on their own terms without the interference of the courts or legislature. Implied terms can be viewed as a technique of construction or interpretation of contracts. It has been argued that the courts are interfering too much in their approach to determine and interpret the terms of a contract. The aim of this essay is to explore this argument further and in doing so consider whether freedom of contract is lost due to courts imposing implied terms. The essay will outline how the common law implies terms. The final part of the essay will examine whether Parliament, by means of a statute, or terms implied by custom restrict freedom in a contract. An overall conclusion on the issue will be reached.
The main focus of this essay will be to examine the reasons behind the laws that
The essay will firstly explore what is clearly working within the system in support of protecting consumer rights. The ACL will be looked at in detail with a focus on product safety as an example.
Using the phone contract selected in P1 and focusing on the customers this briefing sheet will provide an explanation of how a contract protects the customers and what happens if that contract is breached.
There are two main models in the criminal process, the crime control model and the due process model. The crime control model focuses on repression of crime in a speedy and conclusive way. The use of “presumptions of guilt” speeds the process up because very little evidence is needed against the suspect for them to be considered guilty. In this model, it is believed the laws should be stricter, the police force should be increased, and the sentences should be more intense. The due process model has more steps and is more dependable. It focuses more on investigation and finding all the facts. This model pays attention to the person’s rights and liberties as stated in the and the limited powers of the government. The due process model also
The UCTA 1977 was a primary legislative whereas the UTCCR 1999 are an implementation of the European Court’s Directive on Unfair terms in Consumer Contracts. Both the UCTA and UTCCR covered nearly all forms of contracts and one of their most important functions was limiting the applicability of
The main shortcoming of the researches made the well-known authors is the “outsider” view. Moreover, in the judicial and investigative practice and in the legal literature,
This essay will analyse the Consumer Rights Act 2015 (‘CRA 2015’) as it is a significant element of the government’s reform of consumer law in the UK. The Act has been lauded as an immense upheaval of consumer law due to the integration of eight existing pieces of legislation into one. The complicated regulations regarding goods and services that consumers and businesses struggle to comprehend will no longer apply under the Act.
This essay is going to look at the critics of the proposed Bill by the government. Firstly by giving a framework of what is public policy making and distinguish between bill and policy, it’s going to give a brief overview of the policy environment and also the official and unofficial actors involved in the making of the policy as well as their different views about the policy environment. Secondly by giving a definition of a traditional court and also give the background of the proposed traditional court of bill. Therefore discuss Persons and institutions consulted on the bill and the criticism of the bill of the rural women. On the criticism of the bill it appear that the bill is going to oppress women, because is going to enable
The Critical legal studies movement is the successor of an American realist movement. The main characteristic of this movement is the criticism of formalism. The scholars of this movement believe that “techniques of legal reasoning – such as distinguishing cases, interpreting texts or analogizing from one area of law to another where similar problems arise – are so flexible that they can justify more than one outcome”. The scholars of the critical legal studies movement want to achieve is
The objective of this essay is to look at restraints of trade clauses in regards to contracts of employment, and in contracts for sales of a business, which may be used to restrict competition, therefore contradicting the individual liberty of action in trading. From case law it can be shown there is a sharp contrast between the individual liberty and the public policy.
The Cunningham’s objective of their research was to determine how many individuals in various sectors of society know about the consumer protection laws and their rights as consumers. These were included, but not limited to false advertising, false retail advertising, credit regulations, credit cards, labeling, truth in lending and deceptive retail practices. These authors view the consumer relatively weak due to a lack of knowledge. They also feel the low incomes are no match for the sophisticated marketer. There these authors are interested in equity. The most important implication derives from the lack of information demonstrated by all income segments of the consumer sample. This situation suggests that what is needed is not more and tougher laws, but rather more information made available to ore individuals concerning their rights as consumers. The present research has demonstrated that one other variable is important: with the exception of a few areas of the law, both consumers and attorneys know very little about their rights as consumers. This was particularly true in areas such as door-door selling, false or deceptive advertising, false or deceptive retail practices. More and better information concerning consumers’ rights must be provided to individuals of all
1. In addition to the basic consumer rights expressed in the consumer’s Magna Carta, what other expectations do you think consumer stakeholders have of business?
The subject of the research is the law applicable in international commercial arbitration. The paper will first deal with the law applicable to arbitration agreement. Secondly, the question of determination of law applicable to the merits of the dispute will be brought up including the case when the intention of the parties can be found and the situation when there is absence of the choice of law made by the parties. The significance of the selected research topic can be explained by the fact that international commercial arbitral proceedings is widely used by the parties of commercial transactions as the effective method of dispute settlement and the issue of applicable law to the merits of the dispute is one of the main which the arbitral tribunal has to decide.
And so today, it is needed to rely on socio-legal research for law reform, which serve the various purposes such as it suggests a reform in the existing law, socio-legal research, collect, search and make available the legal principle which are useful for society, it suggests a set of rules where no rules exist at all.