preview

Converging Paths : A Critical Review Of The Film 'Babies'

Decent Essays

Converging Paths: A Critical Review of the film, “Babies”
Jeffrey Brown

What an interesting concept for a film / documentary. Following the lives of four babies, this documentary eschewed the routine and simply allowed the viewers to follow and observe the babies’ lives without the trappings of script and dialogue. In addition to simply sitting back and enjoying the movie, one could almost imagine themselves as a scientist conducting an observational experiment. The documentary followed the lives of Bayar, Hattie, Ponijao and Mari. They were born in Mongolia, The United States, Namibia and Japan respectively. The film followed the babies from birth through about the one year mark in essentially the same situations. As such, cultural differences were easily compared and contrasted. This review will be focused on addressing the following questions:
1. How do the children’s environments contribute to their physical, cognitive and emotional/social development?
2. How does the film support or nor support specific human development theories?

How do the Children’s Environments Contribute to their Physical, Cognitive and Emotional/Social Development?
Consistent across the four cultures was the role of the mother. She was the primary caregiver and breastfeeding was common across the cultures. Initially, Ponijao received a lot of direct contact with his mother, while Bayar received the least. In fact, Bayar was separated from his mother at birth and tied to his bed. The Western babies, Hattie and Mari, were exposed to more educational resources and socialization opportunities than the other two. Hattie was constantly read too and attended yoga classes and Mari, while both parents worked, was never alone and likewise well attended too. Ponijao and Bayar were expected to be somewhat more independent. Ponijao’s mother seemed more focused on movement than language. Perhaps a reflection of their culture having more physical requirements than social. Bayar was left alone the most due to the need of the mother to participate in the work of the family. Hygiene was also different across the environments as Ponijao and Bayar were much more in tune to their natural surroundings than the western babies. When they

Get Access