preview

Difference Between Cartesian Dualism

Decent Essays

Today, a forum of Cartesian dualism is arising in the mental health fields. With our ever advancing knowledge in neuroscience, a dichotomy has transpired wherein ‘psychologically based disorders’ are treated with psychotherapy whilst ‘biologically based disorders’ are medicated. (Gabbard, 2000) From the dualist stand point this makes sense as mind and brain --being two separate entities-- should be treated separately. However, the dichotomy makes far less sense when applied to abnormal behaviour, where distinctions between psychological and biological mechanisms are seldom so pronounced. In conditions such as OCD, symptoms often manifest in ways indicative of complex interaction between cognition and neural circuitry, calling for a more holistic view integrating cognitive and biologically based theories as opposed to viewing the two as mutually exclusive.

Arguing against integration are deterministic views of mind; postulating all phenomenon …show more content…

Functional neuroimaging provides data regarding activity in specific structures either during symptom provocation or at rest. This is done by measuring glucose consumption and/or overall localized metabolic rates. The key difference between this quantification and traditional quantifiers of behavioral abnormality is reproducibility, and moreover the elimination of self reporting which –as Hoskin indicates—is inherently flawed. It can be argued that functions of our brain cause our behaviors, but the question of causality has no implication on glucose consumption or metabolic rates because the macroscopic properties are identical in both scenarios. Essentially, a behavior and its neurobiological correlates will be the same irrespective of which gives rise to the other. It is important to note that functional neuroimaging at this point shows only correlative relationships which must not be taken as

Get Access