Today, a forum of Cartesian dualism is arising in the mental health fields. With our ever advancing knowledge in neuroscience, a dichotomy has transpired wherein ‘psychologically based disorders’ are treated with psychotherapy whilst ‘biologically based disorders’ are medicated. (Gabbard, 2000) From the dualist stand point this makes sense as mind and brain --being two separate entities-- should be treated separately. However, the dichotomy makes far less sense when applied to abnormal behaviour, where distinctions between psychological and biological mechanisms are seldom so pronounced. In conditions such as OCD, symptoms often manifest in ways indicative of complex interaction between cognition and neural circuitry, calling for a more holistic view integrating cognitive and biologically based theories as opposed to viewing the two as mutually exclusive.
Arguing against integration are deterministic views of mind; postulating all phenomenon
…show more content…
Functional neuroimaging provides data regarding activity in specific structures either during symptom provocation or at rest. This is done by measuring glucose consumption and/or overall localized metabolic rates. The key difference between this quantification and traditional quantifiers of behavioral abnormality is reproducibility, and moreover the elimination of self reporting which –as Hoskin indicates—is inherently flawed. It can be argued that functions of our brain cause our behaviors, but the question of causality has no implication on glucose consumption or metabolic rates because the macroscopic properties are identical in both scenarios. Essentially, a behavior and its neurobiological correlates will be the same irrespective of which gives rise to the other. It is important to note that functional neuroimaging at this point shows only correlative relationships which must not be taken as
OCD is “a phrase that gets to the existential core of worry, a clenched, demonic doubting that overrides evidence, empiricism, plain common sense” (Slater234). The meme theory states that a meme consists of “everything that is passed from person to person” (Blackmore 37). In “Strange Creatures” by Susan Blackmore and “Who Holds the Clicker?” by Lauren Slater both authors discuss the control humans have over their minds. In “Who Holds the Clicker” Lauren Slater discusses DBS (deep brain simulation), which is a type of psychosurgery in which electrical impulses are sent to certain portions of the brain to control and change the emotions one feels. She discusses both the positive and negatives of deep brain simulation through a specific patient named Mario and also presents the control DBS can have over one’s mind. Similarly, Blackmore in “Strange Creatures” discusses the meme theory, which consists of any idea that is passed down from person to person. Both authors provide information that allows people to draw conclusions relating to why people do not have control over their minds. Even though some people believe that humans do have control over their minds, Blackmore and Slater both successfully portray that in actuality humans do not have any control over their minds because human thoughts and ideas are unoriginal products of external forces, many human thoughts occur at deeper level of consciousness, and
Obsessive compulsive disorder is a disease that many people know of, but few people know about. Many people associate repeated washing of hands, or flicking of switches, and even cleanliness with Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD), however there are many more symptoms, and there are also explanations for those symptoms. In this paper, I will describe what obsessive compulsive disorder is, explain some of the effects of it, and explain why it happens. I will also attempt to prove that while medication doesn’t cure OCD, it vastly improves one’s quality of life. Furthermore I intend to show that behavior therapy (cognitive based therapy) is another useful tool in helping a person to overcome their OCD.
OCD is comprised of several different factors including those on the Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale which are: the amount of time spent on compulsions, inference caused by compulsions to one’s daily activities, the distress caused by compulsions, the ability to resist the compulsion, and the control over the compulsion. By knowing which one of these factors are incorrectly represented by the model, one could work towards augmenting the model in such a way that it better depicts the symptoms and effects of OCD. Theoretically, this augmented model could be used to further research the implications of OCD and possibly develop methods or tools to assist those who suffer from the
Functionalism, one of the most influential and widespread theories of mind of our day, proposes a model of human behaviour based on the way certain inputs are processed when the mind is in a given state, to yield certain outputs. This theory concerns itself only what mental states do, rather than the substance with which they are made, or whether they exist at all; this is called ‘multiple realizability’. In other words, the theory is ontologically modest, or flexible, and this enables functionalism to stay compatible with Cartesian dualism or monisms like materialism, an advantage when other theories lose followers due to their ontological preconceptions. The other notable strength functionalism claims is that it avoids some of the pitfalls of its counterpart theory, behaviourism. However each of these apparent strengths has flaws, both in and of themselves and in comparison to other theories of mind. These strengths and their flaws will be assessed in this essay, but allow me first to outline what the functionalist theory of mind proposes.
Heidegger proposes the definition of metaphysics as dasein. He believes that metaphysics consists of the origins of being and the origins of reality; essentially, beyond the physical. He strongly believes that being only occurs in terms of time. Therefore, he proposes that as humans, we must live in the immediacy of the present moment.
Obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) was once considered a rare disease, but today, it is one of the most prevalent psychological disorders present among society. OCD is described as “intrusive thoughts or images (obsessions), which increase anxiety, and by repetitive or ritualistic actions (compulsions), which decrease anxiety” (Stein, 2002). In the DSM-IV, Obsessive compulsive disorder can be diagnosed through observable behaviours or repetitive mental habits. Symptoms include; the constant washing of hands, and/or fears concerning danger to others or to self – resulting in frequent paranoia. OCD has been linked with lesions in various neurological circuits of the brain due to the consumption of dopamine agonists (for example, cocaine). In order for obsessive compulsive disorder to take clinical significance, dysfunction and distress must follow symptoms. The treatment of OCD was initially developed in the Freudian era, as psychoanalytical treatment was seen as the most effective treatment at the time for mind management. Conversely, recent empirical evidence proved otherwise. Pharmacological therapy and cognitive-behavioural therapy, also known as systematic desensitization are nowadays the most prominent remedies used in treating obsessive compulsive disorder.
Obsessive-compulsive disorder, often referred to as simply OCD, is a mental illness in which an individual experiences endless cycles of repeated thoughts and rituals, known as obsessions and compulsions, which she feels she cannot control (1). Although many people possess habits and routines that help them organize their every day schedules, people with OCD form patterns of behavior that are extremely time-consuming and interfere with their daily lives. Once believed to be a rare and incurable disease which people kept hidden for fear of embarrassment (2), OCD is now recognized as being far more common than previously
One of the more compelling theories of the cause of OCD is the serotonin theory. Two different theories based on serotonin are more prominent than the rest. Giddens (2009) explains the theory by stating that OCD is caused from a lack of a chemical substance called serotonin (a neurotransmitter). Her theory is supported by the use of drugs that increase the amount of serotonin in the brain which relieve many symptoms of OCD. On the other hand, Penzel (2000) describes the serotonin theory as a disrupted transmission of serotonin. When the serotonin is being returned to it’s vesicle chamber, the last step of neural-transmission takes place prematurely, which then causes a brain dysfunction and forms compulsions. Though both serotonin theories do not agree with each other, both theories argue on behalf of nature in the nature versus nurture debate since serotonin and the lack or faulty
Obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) is a debilitating neuropsychiatric disorder with a lifetime prevalence of 2 to 3 percent and is estimated to be the 10th leading cause of disability in the world. Patients with OCD experience recurrent, intrusive thoughts (obsessions) and/or repetitive, stereotyped behaviors (compulsions) that last for at least one hour per day and significantly interfere with the individual 's normal level of functioning. The intrusive obsessional thoughts
Although the Stanford School of Medicine has been able to vouch for the imminent rise of numerous viable medicines – both pharmacological and psycho-therapeutic – medicinal experts are still faced with two main obstacles: to first make these treatments available to all OCD patients; and, second, successfully dissect the scientific background of the disorder well enough to alleviate the manifestation of symptoms present in the sufferer, and conclusively, impede its event. However, before we can potentially pioneer any remedy, it is crucial to understand the etiology behind
Method A, with a total of 40 inpatients (32 females (80 %); mean age=31.25 years) suffering from OCD were randomly assigned to a treatment (administration of additional memantine) or a control group (which was the placebo). The treatment had lasted for 12 consecutive weeks, and all patients were treated with selective serotonin inhibitors, or clomipramine. The patients had to complete the Yale–Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale four times.
the more common and serious mental conditions. Studies conducted in the field of OCD have
1. What is Cartesian dualism? - Cartesian Dualism is a term that was originated in Greek philosophy that refer to as a theory or system of thought that regards a domain of reality in terms of two independent principles which are the mind/soul and body. Rene Descartes reinforced this concept and gave it a name, dualism due to the mind, body, and soul. In other word, Rene Descartes determined that the information comes through the brain and sent to soul.
The intricate design of the human brain encompassing the neocortex lobes, the elaborate web of synapses and the fundamental cerebellum is increasingly relevant to contemporary clinical and psychological developments. There is nothing greater than the mystery that masquerades the convoluted nature of the human brain and thus studying psychology has always been of great appeal to me. Having read “Is That My Child: A Guide to Dyspraxia, Dyslexia, ADD, ADHD, OCD and Tourette's syndrome”, I have gauged an understanding into the fragility of the human mind and how each segment plays a vital part in the functioning of the human body. Having experienced a close family member suffer with a neurological disorder, my desire to gain an extensive knowledge of the subject has
The trend of neurobiology and physiology predicting and causing behavioris not a new fact. So many illnesses and diseases are now attributed to biological mechanisms. A recent article in Newsweek comments on how those in the field of psychology and neuroscience are beginning to stress the fact that certain brain mechanisms account for mental illnesses and particular behaviors. Doctors seem to blame their patients peculiarities on a biologically based mental illness, rather then seeing them as individual responses to lifes circumstances (Begley 1998). It then becomes more common to prescribe drugs to alleviate the symptoms rather than understanding the behavior. Two recent developments have