preview

Discrimination In The Child Welfare System

Decent Essays

children, the option of adoption still remains complicated, as disabled individuals are often viewed as incapable as parents in this culture (Lightfoot et al., 2010; Smith, 2015).
To protect the parenting rights of disabled individuals, the systemic and legal barriers restricting them must be removed, as it is clear that many face undue discrimination in the child welfare system. These restrictions also include those witnessed by disabled people attempting to pursue assistive reproductive technology because they cannot or do not wish to bear biological children on their own. The same eugenic beliefs that led health care professionals to the widespread use of sterilization for women with disabilities now leads to diminished access to reproductive …show more content…

society seems to be that disabled people cannot be effective parents. Disability-lawyer Carrie Ann Lucas shared her experiences with USA Today (2012), witnessing “parents with paralysis be threatened with removal of their children, deaf parents punished for using sign language with their hearing children, and blind parents told that a social worker can’t possibly fathom how they could parent a newborn.” Lucas adds that “when families do need intervention, it is often because the services they need are not available outside a punitive social services case.” It is important to note the unfair standards of independence that disabled parents face in the U.S. Research shows that these parents can often prove themselves competent with some support services, but child welfare systems and the general public may question that aid, as they may be seen as a lack of the self-sufficiency valued in U.S. culture. Utilizing multiple systems of support can lead to improved parenting and family cohesion, and so should be viewed as a benefit instead of a deficiency in an individual’s capacity to provide parental care. In fact, according to the 2012 NCD report, disabled parents whose abilities in this area are questioned often confront inappropriate or unfair assessments (Smith, …show more content…

While there is some slow improvement in the U.S. towards upholding disabled rights with improved consideration of capacity to consent and best interests, the stigma around the disabled continues, especially when it comes to reproduction and parenting, and media representations of this population perpetuate stereotypes about alleged unfitness to parent and function in society. Feminist conversations around rights of the disabled and ethical medical and legal treatment may be an important piece missing from mainstream discussions around reproductive rights. It is crucial for the well-being of disabled individuals to further increase the awareness of physicians, support service workers and caretakers, and the general public when it comes to these issues and the practice of using the least restrictive options when dealing with sexual and reproductive needs of women with

Get Access