Dr Sparrow And Whitmore

Better Essays
Ethics Case Study Perhaps some of the most difficult things a psychologist may deal with are ethical dilemmas. An ethical dilemma is a situation in which a person has to choose between two or more options, but the outcome will not satisfy all parties involved or satisfy in an equal manner. Every person has or will come in contact with an ethical dilemma at some point in their life. In order to demonstrate some of the situations a psychologist may come in contact with, case studies are given and studied in order to better future decisions in times of ethical dilemmas. One example of an ethical dilemma is the case study of Dr. Sparrow and Wilf Whitmore. This case study is centered on Whitmore’s calculation error of drugs in the reduction of allergy…show more content…
In order to do that, it is important to know the approaches. Utilitarian, rights, justice, common good, and virtue approaches are the five basic approaches to ethical decision making. In the utilitarian approach, the option that is best will produce the most good and do the least harm. If Dr. Sparrow were to choose this option, she would most likely inform Whitmore of his error and dismiss Whitmore’s incorrect information, and keep his correct and relevant data. In this option, Whitmore learns of his mistake without penalization and no incorrect data is included in Dr. Sparrow’s paper for future use. In the rights approach, the option that is best respects the rights of all who have a stake. In this option, Dr. Sparrow would most likely inform her coauthors and the test subjects of the mistake and then dismiss any incorrect data or redo the experiment. In this situation, all are informed about the mistake, but the mistake does not affect future studies or…show more content…
In this situation, Dr. Sparrow would most likely inform all who are involved with and affected by the mistake and dismiss Whitmore’s information on Drug A. This way, everyone knows of the mistake, but no one is harmed by it. In the virtue approach, the option that is best leads you to act as the sort of person you want to be. In this situation, Dr. Sparrow may dismiss the incorrect information and inform Whitmore of his mistake. This way, the data doesn’t affect anyone, and Whitmore learns of his mistake without harsh punishment. If I were to choose which option I would go with, I would go with the justice approach because it doesn’t keep anyone who deserves to know the mistake out of it, and it also ensures that everyone learns that mistakes have consequences. If I told someone I respected of my option, I don’t think they’d agree right away, but over time they’d understand my decision. At first, they’d probably say I’m being too harsh because it was just an accident, but then they may be able to see that it becomes an example for double checking work and not having an incident like that in the future. Falsification, fabrication, and plagiarism are not something to be taken lightly, otherwise, it becomes okay for future use or easy to
Get Access