Finally, when Jigs says that she wants him to stop talking, it means that she has accepted the abortion to save their relationship. Together with the other symbols of the drinks to wipe out her morals and the beads that hint that she gives in to the abortion, it makes sense that she will give in to the abortion, and she wants him to stop trying to convince her with his empty assurances and words (Flora 51). When the American announces that he will bring the bags to the other side of the tracks, she smiles since she is contented that she has a moment alone to grief. However, she does not want him to leave her for eternity. Thus, she proposes that he can come back later to finish their drink (Hemingway 255). When the American comes back, she smiles again, for she knows that she must hide her true feelings to save this relationship and that her crying will result in him leaving her. Hashmi claims that when he gets a drink on his own, the incoming end of their relationship is already hinted at (80). She says that she is alright, but in the inside she is devastated, and …show more content…
Even though he seems to give her a choice, the abortion is the only option. There seems to be plenty symbols that indicate her decision to abort her baby, such as the cloud that predicts the abortion, the drinks to drown her consciousness and the curtain that confirms her decision. As the majority of the critics in the sources that I have found seem to be opting for the abortion, it became evident that this was a solid interpretation of the story. Thus, it is clear that the abortion will happen. However, whether it will matter for their relationship can also be interpreted in different ways. This analysis did not focus on that aspect of the story although it can be an interesting topic for further
A book of American martyrs has an abrupt start. Luther murders Voorhees on the front page, and also his escort by the way. And yet it is not a book that deals with abortion, at least not only. But it begins and we start with a dead protagonist, and the other locked up. And, like Oates gives voice to Luther but not to Gus (Voorhees), the reader will receive a little more information on the first than on the second, which comes to us based on memories, opinions of others... but they are dead. So the novel sets its gaze on the families of both, two unhappy families and intertwined by the tragic event. But very different, especially because, as Gus's daughter says, they don't have a father. Families through which time passes and that live the different
Jig’s personal growth over the course of this conversation also proves that she did not follow through with this abortion. “Is it good with water?” (Hemingway 229). Here she is asking the man whether or not it is good with water, her decision directly depends on whether or not he believes it is good with water. She is depending on him to make a decision that directly affects her. “Everything tastes like licorice. Especially all the things you’ve waited so long for, like absinthe” (Hemingway 230). Jig is being sarcastic with this remark, this is the first sign that she is willing to go against the man and think for herself, even if the man does not like what she says. Jig also says that they were all so happy after their abortions when the man states that he knows other people who have gone through this (Hemingway 230). She says this sarcastically and here you get to see how she really feels underneath about this procedure. She is thinking for herself and not just doing whatever the man tells her to do. “Would you please please please please please please please stop talking?” (Hemingway 232). Jig has grown to stand up for herself. She no longer cares what the man has to say about the
It is implied that Jig does not want an abortion from some of the dialogs such as when she says, “We could have all this,” “we could have everything” (par. 71). Though she does not say it clearly, it implies that she dreams of having the baby and having a future together as a family. She also describes the baby as something precious; “once they take it away, you never get it back” (par. 81). The baby is something that she will never be able to bring back after giving up. And, she does not want to let go. However, after he keeps mentioning about an abortion, she says people who get an abortion become happy; “And afterward they were all happy” (par. 54). Like previously stated, it is implied that she does not want an abortion. Yet, she still says, “Then I’ll do it. Because I don’t care about me” (par. 64). This is an irony and sarcasm because she cares about herself and her baby, but she says the opposite. She says she will get an abortion and be happy afterward, making the conversation superficial like the man does. She tries to tell him that she wants to keep a baby; however, she does not say her opinion or her true feeling, and fails to have a communication with
Yet the girl seems to think about how their lives will turn out for the good or bad. Hints while she talks about a white elephant, which is a gift that a person may not for the most part want or something that doesn’t fit into their lives. From a view point Jig’s unborn child is (the white elephant). It is obvious that the child isn’t suitable into the American’s life, hence him asking Jig to have the operation. An operation that he assures her is ‘really an awfully simple operation.’ In the story the girl says, “and if I do it you’ll be happy and things will be like they were and you’ll love me?” http://mycours.es/gamedesign2012 Likewise the man truly believes but doesn’t say that having the child would lead them to breaking up and is the reason for them having
One way Hemingway uses symbolism to explain how the man and woman have different thoughts about their relationship. For example, “ the station was between two lines of rails” , this may mean that their relationship is at a crossroad, because the rails have different destinations which in turn means that the man and women have a different idea for the future of their relationship. Another example is the quote, “they look like white elephants” the woman says this when referring to the hills. She is trying to tell the man that the baby she is expecting is like a “white elephant” because it is like an unwanted gift or something that's hard to dispose of. We have to keep in mind that during this time period in which this took place abortion was
Finally the girl cannot bear her companion’s selfish urgings anymore and asks him to stop talking. The repetition of the word “please” (255) seven times implies it is more than a question. As Renner states, the repetition shows indirectly her refusal to accept his attempts to convince her to abort the foetus. Besides, the American’s hypocrisy is reflected when he looks at their bags: “ There were labels on them from all the hotels where they had spent nights. “(Hemingway 255). The hotels’ labels represent the pleasure of the careless nights they had spent together which the American wants to maintain by undergoing the abortion. The American says, “ I don’t care anything about it.” (Hemingway 255), but it is clear from his gaze at the bags that
The man is not very sincere when he constantly tells the girl she doesn't have to have the operation of she doesn't want to. He repeats himself - times which makes it makes it seem as though he is trying to convince her that she has the option to choose whatever she wants and he’ll be on her side. But I think if she did choose not to have the abortion the man would leave her.
Ernest Hemingway relied on experiences and the time period that he wrote the novel The Sun Also Rises. Hemingway used symbolism and irony to express his own experiences that he went through after the war, in this novel. Gertrude Stein named the generation of adults that lived during World War I, "The Lost Generation."People thought the phrase holds true to some people who fought or were involved in the war. Hemingway quotes Stein in passages saying "The world remains and the sun continues to rise and set." The Sun Also Rises first appeared in 1926.
However, The American’s feeling suggests to the readers his agreement on abortion, which symbolizes death. As the American states to Jig, “I know we will. You don’t have to be afraid. I’ve knows lots of people that have done it” (402). The American states his feeling after Jig states, “And you think then we’ll be all right and be happy” (402). Literally, the American wants Jig to have an abortion because he does not want to settle down and raise a family. Instead, he wanted to continue his trip around the world. As the author states, “He did say anything but looked at the bags... There were labels on them from all the hotels where they had spent nights” (403). The bag that has all the labels from all the hotels brings evidence that the American likes living his life by having trips and not by making a family. Therefore, symbolically, when
Ernest Hemingway was an American writer. He was born in 1899 in Oak Park, Illinois. He committed suicide in 1961 in Ketchum, Idaho (Burges 17). Even today Hemingway is one of the most recognized authors in the world. Hemingway’s experiences during World War I are directly shown in many of his works. His general outlook on life is reflected in the adventures of his characters. It is clear that Hemingway had a desire to be part of the war even though, due to bad vision he was unable to enlist in the army and fight in the war. Instead he lied about his age and went to Italy to become an ambulance driver. While in Italy he experienced many things that he would later go on to write about in works such as A Farewell to Arms and For Whom the
*Disclaimer: I could not find the rubric to complete this task and have a sinking feeling that this is way too long. Please have patience, and someone point me into the direction for next time?
Ernest M. Hemingway Ernest Miller Hemingway was a novelist and short story writer, who became well known for the passion that he used in all his writings. Many of his works are regarded as classics of American Literature, and some have even been made into motion pictures. The Old Man and the Sea, which is the story about an old Cuban fisherman, was published in 1952. Because of this creation, in 1954 Hemingway was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature.
Are you a man? Have you ever dealt with the issue of losing or being in the process of losing a child in which you took part in making? It’s difficult to truthfully answer these questions if you’re not a man and if you haven’t experienced abortion first hand. January 22, 1973 marked the beginning of a moral and political revolution in this country that would forever change many lives 1. The landmark decision ruled constitutional by the Supreme Court to legalize abortion with unrestricted procedures would profoundly affect women and men’s lives. But the American society forgot half of the population that would be traumatized by this experience, just because they were men. Throughout the limited information
With the way the American man urges the girl to have the operation, although not forcefully, it can be thought that he sees the girl’s pregnancy as the source of their problems. The girl, while obviously reluctant to the idea of having an abortion, is caught between wanting to keep the child and making the man happy. This is common to women wanting to have abortion and having second thoughts. Their vague conversation ends with a subliminal message that the girl will go through abortion, and their relationship will remain the way it is. The story shows no development to the characters or the
In the “Hills like white elephants,” I believe Jig notice and understand the feelings of what she wants for the unexpected pregnancy but because of Jig being passive and pleasing the American man or looking at the American man for answer. She soon realizes that relationship will not be the same with or without the procedure because the opposition between the American’s values and Jig are too different. The story revolves around the development of the girl character and the dialogue between the American about the hills and drinks struggle over whether if their relationship will change and how it affects their lifestyle. From the American man point view it will complicated his freedom and unable to travel or stay in many leisure hotels or has the child and settle down to a conventional marriage. Jig’s view the unexpected pregnancy as rewarding because she always wants a child and a normal life. The American man constantly argues for the abortion but also reassure her that nothing will change after the procedure however Jig character is still being develop therefore she always doing what he wants because she does not want the relationship to end which lead me to believe his dominate in the couple’s relationship or on how he manages their relationship together in a manner to his own desires.