2. Summarize the essential aspects of the American healthcare system, highlighting how American health care has evolved since World War Two (eg., who has health insurance, how expensive is health care, what citizen-patient outcomes/life expectancy look like, etc.).
If you want to understand why we are the only developed country with an employer-based health insurance — really, the only one — then you had better get familiar with the Internal Revenue Code of 1954.
The 1954 code is the document in which the federal government codified into law that companies can provide health insurance benefits to workers tax-free. This affirmed a 1943 IRS Tax Court ruling that had also decreed health benefits to be nontaxable.
The early decisions were made in the context of a wartime tax code. There were overwhelming taxes meant to stop wartime profiteering and keep unions from shutting down production to extract wage gains. However, when health care was protected from these taxes, it immediately became of great value to workers, and companies were able to keep it tax-free even after the war. The result is that a dollar in health benefits is worth more to a worker than a dollar in wages because the dollar in health benefits is untaxed and the dollar in wages is taxed. Melissa Thomasson, an economist at Miami University who has written extensively on the history of health insurance reminds us that it is a huge discount off the price of health insurance, and it happened very quietly.
Prior to this shift, government involvement in health insurance services was minimal since it seemed to be under control by the non-profit sector. There didn’t seem to be an urgent need to control or universalize health care at the time. The government’s first interest in the health care industry sparked when employers began providing health care benefits as a competitive advantage for recruiting workers back into the workforce during World War II. To help cope with the rising unemployment rates, the government would offer tax incentives to employers providing these benefits. (add Quote)
The first characteristic of the US health care system is that there is no central governing agency which allows for little integration and coordination. While the government has a great influence on the health care system, the system is mostly controlled through private hands. The system is financed publically and privately creating a variety of payments and delivery unlike centrally controlled healthcare systems in other developed countries. The US system is more complex and less manageable than centrally controlled health care systems, which makes it more expensive. The second characteristic of the US health care system is that it is technology driven and focuses on acute care. With more usage of high technology,
Since insurance companies are required to provide care, it makes sense to buy insurance only when you need it. In other words, wait until you get sick to buy insurance, because they cannot turn you down. In order to combat this, the law includes an individual mandate, which requires anyone that can afford it to buy health insurance, or pay a penalty to the IRS. In essence, this is the part of the law that pays for it all. This is also the section many Republicans hate. In their philosophy, the government cannot force someone to buy something they may or may not need. They argued that this law was unconstitutional, and they sued in federal court to have the law nullified. There were three cases overall: one from the states (Florida v. U.S. Dept. of Health and Human Svcs.), one from the federal government (U.S. Dept. of Health and Human Svcs. v. Florida), and one from the National Federation of Independent Business (Nat'l Fed. of Independent Bus. v. Sebelius). Due to conflicting rulings from the lower courts in
For many years, the organizations had purchased life insurance for their employees, the key reason is that through some key personnel from the insurance company to maintain their own financial loss on their lives when events occur (Martin, 2010). On the other hand, the insurance company by emphasizing their tax advantages, to encourage corporations to purchase the corporate-owned life insurance. The goal of corporate-owned life insurance is corporations need to take large loans in order to pay for the insurance fee and make the maximize profits of tax. At the same time, the corporations can get a large amount of income tax from their interest payment. However, in 1986, the insurance organizations established new form which named Tax Reform
If an employer has 15 or more employees and the employer does not have health insurance for them, the government is going to subsided them, but the employer is going to pay a find, since the employees do not get pay enough to buy the
2. Here, the research shows that in many situations, healthcare professionals are urged to conduct unnecessary tests and procedures in order to rack up the bill for insurance claims to then
In the beginning of the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, the “healthcare system” was left in the hands of the states, which the states handed off to private and voluntary programs to deal with. In the presidential term of Teddy Roosevelt, 1901-1909, he felt that “no country could be strong whose people were sick and poor.” (Palmer 1999) He did however back health insurance as a whole. Roosevelt was not the one fighting for the health care though, there were outside forces that impacted health care. The American Association of Labor Legislation (AALL) led the campaign for health insurance. They drafted their first bill by 1915. This bill wanted to limit the coverage toward the working class and anyone who earned less than $1,200 a year including dependents. The American Medical Association (AMA) backed this bill because they felt the same way about coverage. The AMA did not speak for all doctors and those who opposed this backing spoke up. The American Federation of Labor (AFL) opposed the bill because they felt that it would weaken the unions and they wanted to maintain their strength. The private insurance
Prior to the nation experiencing globalization and free trade, businesses were designed as employee based models, freely offering health care coverage to their
What role does early American history have to play in the quest for Universal Health Coverage in the U.S. during the 20th century?
The health reform bill was enacted by the Congress based largely on the free market and has been criticized for significantly enhancing government regulation of health insurers. However, critics of this law have failed to highlight that it established a system that relies on private companies and the government neither nationalized doctors, nor seized control of institutions offering health care to citizens.
Kliff explains that the decision to provide these health benefits at this time was made in the shadow of a wartime tax code. There were taxes put into place that were meant to stop wartime exploitation and help to keep the unions from shutting down production to extract wage gains. However, when health care was protected from these taxes, it immediately became of great value to employees, and companies benefited as they were able to keep it tax-free even after the war had ended (Kliff, 2015).
We have seen over the timeline of development that both countries reacted differently to the outcomes of World War II. In the United States, the 1954 Internal Revenue Service Tax Code, in which the government codified into the law that companies can provide health insurance benefits to workers tax-free, is a reason for the difference. When healthcare was protected from taxes, it became very valuable to workers and companies. The result was that a dollar in health benefits is worth more to a worker than a dollar in wages, because the dollar in health benefits is untaxed and the dollar in wages is taxed. However, today, the health insurance tax break is the biggest in federal budget; the government loses out on $260 billion annually by not taxing health benefits (Kliff, 2015). The majority of non-elderly Americans get their health
In 1943, employer-based health care became tax-free by the Internal Revenue Service. By 1960s, around 70 percent of the public was covered by private or voluntary health insurance plan. In 2010, The U.S. Congress marked the greatest change in our health policy since the 1960s. This is when Congress enacted the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. This law was intended to address the fundamental problems of the health care system.
Throughout the first part of the 20th century there was little effort to promote health insurance, but in the second half of the 20th century healthcare became a major concern. Once, Medicare and Medicaid were introduced in 1965 the government along with its citizens took a major step in the progression of healthcare. From then, there was a shift in the privatization of healthcare. This forced many of the lower class to be without health insurance. In 1993, President Clinton with the best of in intentions failed at establishing a universal healthcare system in the United States. Finally in 2006, Massachusetts passed a law that would provide healthcare coverage for all of its state residents. In 2010 the
Public policy is very important, as it sets the stage for many different laws and regulations (Cohen, 2012). The law addressed here is the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010, more commonly known as "Obamacare." The law is designed to ensure that everyone in the United States has healthcare coverage, but it also requires the vast majority of people to have that coverage (Patient, 2010). There are many supporters of the law, since it gives those with pre-existing medical conditions a chance to get healthcare at reasonable rates. However, there are also many people who are against the new law because they feel they should not be forced to buy insurance or anything else from the government. The US government is calling Obamacare a "tax," in order to get around provisions that state the government cannot require citizens to buy products or services from the government. Not everyone is happy about the way the healthcare law has been created or enacted, but regardless of any of that there are many public policy issues that surround the healthcare law.