preview

Gender Testing: True Or False?

Decent Essays

Micah Nibbs
Gender Testing: True or False?
Greg Johnson
Composition II
M/W 3:30

In recent years there has been one topic that has been pulled to the forefront of the literary world. That topic is the debate over whether or not a persons gender can be determined by their writing. There have been several studies done to determine whether or not this can be done. These studies have led to a number of tests and websites that are said to be able to determine whether or not there is a noticeable gap or difference in the styles that have been presented by authors of different genders. With the rise of these types of things there has also inevitably been a number of problems that go hand in hand with them. The question of whether or not these …show more content…

The first of these was “The Birth of 'The New Journalism'; Eyewitness Report” by Tom Wolfe. I used the first and second paragraph of this essay as my tester. The results that I got were once again correct, for an informal essay the verdict was 62.16% male and 71.07% for a formal essay. Now so far the results have seemed to be pretty accurate except for the one “mistake”. I then decided to test another female writer and plugged in the fourth paragraph from “Joan Didion:The Only Disconnect” by Barbara Harrison. The results for this one were once again male, testing out at 84.36% male for an informal essay, and at 54.41% male (weak emphasis indicates European). This was another incorrect result and made me wonder if the site was unfairly biased towards. I decided to conduct more tests. I plugged in paragraphs from writers such as J.K Rolling, Harper Lee, Agatha Christie, and all of these female writers came out as male. I also plugged in speeches from famous politicians such as Hillary Clinton (came out as a strong male), Bill Clinton (a weak female), and Barack Obama (once again a weak female). This led me to consider another alternative (or alternatives), are the more educated/professional writers mostly being considered male? Can the setting of a speech or a written work determine the results? Is the site simply associating emotion with gender identity, considering the more emotional writing female, and the less emotional writing

Get Access