preview

Germ-Line Engineering In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

Decent Essays

Some scientists also fail to see any benefits of this technology and believe that germ-line engineering fails to be necessary. They “are adamant that germ-line engineering is being pushed ahead with ‘false arguments’” (Regalado). Through in vitro fertilization, people fertilize several embryos in order to choose a healthy embryo that lacks the disease-causing gene. This process eliminates disease from the offspring without altering the genes of all future generations, and this form of fertilization is understood and accepted with no chance of unknown, negative effects. Many scientists agree that germ-line engineering, in which this technology is used to alter embryos and pass changes to offspring and all future generations, is unethical …show more content…

However, the technology remains largely inaccurate, and more research should be conducted to determine if any lasting negative effects exist. Germ-line engineering will alter all future generations, so consequences of this technology need to be understood before subjecting future generations to unknown side effects. In her novel Frankenstein, Mary Shelley argues that Victor Frankenstein created a monster through his scientific discoveries. She warns against the dangers of scientific advancement and clearly illustrates where Frankenstein crosses the line to monstrous creations when he gives life to an eventually murderous being. Her argument does still apply today; researchers have a responsibility to their work and to society. Scientists are driven by curiosity and a desire to help others, as expressed by Robert Walton in Frankenstein: “[Y]ou cannot contest the inestimable benefit which I shall confer on all mankind to the last generation” (Shelley 2). Researchers, such as Walton, aim to help the human race in some way, but they should ensure the quality and safety of their discoveries before unleashing them on society. However, scientists should also listen to the opinions and attitudes of people toward the technology before releasing it to the public. Currently, people are still wary of genetic engineering and its

Get Access