preview

Health System ( Phs )

Decent Essays

On November 18, 2015 and December 2, 2015, an arbitration took place between Pennbanana Health System (PHS) – the Defendant – and three nurses who were employed there – the Plaintiff, but lost their jobs on account of insubordination. There was an outbreak of Ebola in this hospital, resulting in one of these nurses getting the disease. All three nurses refused working with another Ebola patient after the first patient had died approximately a month prior. Soon after the firing, the Board of Trustees for PHS released a statement to the press that pertained to the reasoning of the nurses’ firing. Personally, if I were an arbitrator, I would not find the Board of Trustees for Pennbanana Health System or the hospital itself liable for any …show more content…

Although the nurses did go through a traumatic experience when caring for an Ebola patient who died, they clearly refused work, without offering to work with another patient. From the moment these individuals became nurses, they knew that they would have a duty to care for people enduring illnesses.
2. Did any breach a duty? If so, how did the breach occur? If not, how did the Plaintiffs fail to prove breach?
According to Merriam Webster, a breach is defined as a failure to act in a promised or required way. As mentioned, these nurses knew their responsibilities of working with sick individuals upon beginning work at a facility and likely before going to college to complete a degree in nursing. It is a requirement of the nurses to care for patients due to it being their job description and the reasoning for why they were hired at PHS. I am unaware of how many staff members of PHS are nurses, however, if three are refusing an assignment, it is likely that the hospital procedures for caring for patients was jeopardized. After all, if the hospital was short-staffed, it was likely that each patient wasn’t getting the adequate care that they needed.
3. Were any injuries suffered? If so, who? If not, how did the Plaintiffs fail to prove injury?
The nurses each shared their stories to how they had suffered as a result of caring for patients with Ebola, as well as through the loss of their jobs at PHS. All three of the

Get Access