preview

What Role Did The Individual And Group Play In This Case Leesa Memoir

Better Essays

1. The individual or group that had their rights infringed – who were they? The individual or group that had their rights infringed were single as well as lesbian women who were denied IVF treatment because they weren’t married. In this case Leesa Meldrum’s rights were infringed. Leesa Meldrum was the patient of Dr John McBain, who’s a specialist IVF doctor. 2. Which right(s) was infringed? How was the right(s) infringed? The rights that were infringed were the rights to have access to IVF treatment as a single woman. These rights were infringed when Leesa Meldrum was denied the service for the reason of being a single woman. This meant she wasn’t following the requirements that were needed to receive the treatment. According to The Victorian Infertility Act 1995 in order to receive IVF treatment you have to be married or in a de facto relationship, therefore single and homosexual women we’re denied the service. 3. …show more content…

What role did the individual or group play in taking this case to court? What/ who encouraged them? The role that the individual or groups played in this case was as the defendant. A specialist IVF doctor, Dr John McBain was affected by this issue. By denying lesbian as well as single women patients access to IVF treatment he was following the requirements of the Victorian Infertility Treatment Act but also going against the Commonwealth sex discrimination Act. What encouraged Dr John McBain to go ahead with the case was that a specific patient, Leesa Meldrum, was denied the service of IVF, therefore he felt the need to bring this case to

Get Access