preview

Hillbilly Elegy Memoir

Decent Essays

Memoir Essay Memoirs, and writing in general, reveal a truth about the author. Oftentimes, said truth is revealed intentionally. Universal truths such as struggle, endurance, and agony help authors influence their audiences. These truths cause the readers to become cognizant of and appreciate the authors. It is a writer’s duty to write from the heart—to write about the good and bad sides of a story. Annie Dillard’s An American Childhood fails to use universal truths and instead presents a very superficial presentation of its author’s life. J. D. Vance’s Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis display the unconventional upbringing of Vance in order to give the audience a better understanding of the writer. Pure honesty …show more content…

Her mother often lectured against conformity, but Dillard fails to analyze or fully understand them: “Torpid conformity was a kind of sin; it was stupidity itself, the mighty stream against which Mother would never cease to struggle” (Dillard 116). Dillard simply states her mother’s opinion, without any personal input. With only shallow writing, the audience is unable to connect with the author and her meaning. Some may argue that her use of logic allows the audience to comprehend her values; however, the audience’s comprehension from logic is extremely shallow compared to an understanding based on feeling. While the reader may understand why one may have certain values, he or she will not fully grasp how those values affect one’s actions or why those values have such an impact on one’s life. Mamaw showed her values and influenced Vance through non-verbal honesty. Her sacrifice spoke for her, unlike Dillard’s description of her mother. One author shows how effective people in his life were by presenting honest examples that do not necessarily portray him in a positive light while the author presents simple, superficial examples and fails to connect with her audience. Honesty in Hillbilly Elegy helps the author present his message. Vance portrays his message of the deterioration of the white working class through all of the experiences he

Get Access