preview

Holding Therapy

Better Essays

Holding Therapy

What is Holding Therapy?

Holding therapy was developed by Dr. Martha Welch in the late 1970s. Dr. Welch was a psychiatrist in New York who began using it with children with autism. Later, she outlined her form of therapy in a book titled, Holding Time (Welch, 1988). Originally, Dr. Welch discovered holding therapy with autistic children. Later, however, she began using this therapy with typical children as well and, in her opinion, discovered equally satisfying results. Welch currently refers to her therapy as Regulatory Bonding Therapy. Holding therapy is a technique that requires the mother of a child with autism to hold her child for a period of time, even if the child is resisting. The mother holds on to …show more content…

Her parents report that she was forced to drink a lot of water as a punishment for taking a soft drink without permission. They claim that the Cascade Center gave them this discipline advice as part of their holding therapy program. The Cascade Center vehemently denies that such advice was given. However, as a result, the practices of holding therapy have come under considerable scrutiny and may be outlawed in Utah legislature (Hunt, Herrick & Hyde). On the Cascade Center website, VanBloem states that holding therapy is supported by research. However, he does not cite any of this research and later claims that “the best proof of the effectiveness of holding therapy is the people who show up at town meetings to defend it” (Hunt). Again, anecdotal evidence seems to be the best evidence cited for this form of therapy.

Evidence Against the Effectiveness of
Holding Therapy

Perhaps the best evidence against holding therapy is in the very basic presumptions about the aetiology of autism itself. If holding therapy is rooted in the belief that the mother-child relationship is dysfunctional, then current knowledge about the aetiology of autism has understandably brought the effectiveness of holding therapy into question. Again, the lack of rigorous research on this topic

Get Access