preview

Hugo Cabret's How Multicultural Is Your Diverse?

Decent Essays

We have observed how images hold “hidden messages”, discovered who Hugo Cabret is with the help of childhood models, now it is time to unveil how the setting of a story and multicultural within a story, can effect the perception of the read. Stacy Whitman states her findings in Obeso’s discussion, “How Multicultural Is Your Multiverse?” when she states, “there are a lot of mirrors for white readers, who can see themselves represented in fiction, but not quite as many for people of color” (Obeso) In Reading Children’s Literature, Hintz and Tribunella demonstrate that, “when we think about the audience of a book, we need to think about the experiences that can lead to different reader responses.” (361 Hintz, Tribunella) Together, their statements …show more content…

A sacred child’s view on Hugo’s situation, however, may differ and appear to the reader as an unbearable circumstance. A child who is presented with meals when he or she is hungry and toys when he or she is bored, could feel as though Hugo’s struggles is oppressive. During the read, we view an example similar to the child of poverty versus the sacred child, when we observe the differences between Hugo and his friend Isabelle. Isabelle who is the goddaughter of Mr. Melies lives in his house and spends her days reading for pleasure in the library of the station. Although she has a roof over her head, food, and people who care for her, which Hugo does not, they do find common ground. At the end of the novel George Melies reveals “And just when I thought it couldn’t get any worse, two of my dearest friends, a young cameraman and his wife, were killed in a terrible car accident. But their baby daughter survived.” (405 Selznick) Hugo and Isabelle find mutual respect and confidentiality in one another with the knowledge that both of them are

Get Access