preview

John Stewart Bridges Not Walls Critique

Decent Essays

I care, therefore I criticize is the statement made by John Stewart in chapter seven of his book on Bridges Not Walls: A book about interpersonal communication. As a mother, this writer feels that it’s an obligation to tell your children when they are doing wrong or head down the wrong past because you care. When your children become adults the obligation is still there, but the statement does not mean the same. The word criticize implies making fault of someone observed mistakes. When you care the criticism is presented in a good way. Therefore I criticize in a more friendly way. Stewart shared a very interesting story of a woman from Thailand that this writer can relate to when it comes to caring and criticizing your children. The …show more content…

It’s a difficult task to sort both of them out due the levels in which language works. Stewart explains the two level of language is the message and the meta-message. The message is the spoken words and the meta-message is the unspoken words, both messages can be reciprocated (Stewart, 2012, 244-247). If this writer would change Stewart’s statement of “I Care, Therefore I Criticize”, it would be “I Care, Therefore I Critique. Critique is a form of criticism, but it’s less fault finding and more of an objective assessment. The objective assessment could be comments both positive and negative, but the end result is always impersonal and the intent is to improve whatever the situation maybe. Criticism at times is personal and many times taken as offensive. This writer tries to give objective criticism to the adult child, by listening, observing and sometime getting in involved, which in turn is considered giving caring advice. This friendly criticism or in other words critique is given to improve, encourage, protect, and to help succeed in life. Looking or sitting on the other side of the table, this writer can see how the adult child could interpret the good intention as control. As a mother, connection and control is how the nurturing process begins. The connection creates the bond and the control creates the relationship between the two. As the child matures there’s less control and

Get Access