preview

Plurality In The 18th Century

Decent Essays

The views of plurality changed significantly between 1800 and 1900. The 18th century was a time of scientific reasoning and the rejecting of religious beliefs. The 19th century sparked a debate on the combination of extraterrestrial life and religion. New discoveries by astronomers found ways to argue for anti-plurality by using religious viewpoints. William Whewell was one of the first astronomers to bring about this new argument. Alfred Wallace also brought the theory of evolution into the argument against plurality. Plurality is not possible in the universe because the Earth is in such a perfect spot for life to exist and those same conditions would not come about again for another planet to sustain life.
At the time, William Whewell created …show more content…

Plurality is not possible because God created the Earth with waste in mind. There are trees, acorns, frogs, and many other things that are wasted on this Earth, but God created those waste items to actually serve a purpose. The Earth has deserts that are thought to be wasteful but actually serve a purpose in the environment. Dust from deserts help hold water in the atmosphere and maintains the water cycle. God intended for it to be this way, and only on Earth, which is why we have the atmosphere we do. We are unique and special in the universe and we had an intelligent creator who designed the universe for Earth and Earth only. Intelligent beings are not plausible anywhere else in the universe.
Alfred Wallace was one of the first to use the theory of evolution to conclude that the possibility of life on other planets is possible. For life to exist on other planets, there would have to be such perfect conditions to align again, those close to the conditions Earth had when life started. Whewell based his beliefs on astronomy and he believed that humans were unique in nature. Whewell also claimed that since the Earth was special, it was in the center of the universe, the perfect place to sustain life. Whewell claimed that the universe was in fact not infinite and the stars proved why. Wallace

Get Access