preview

Podcast Serial Case Study

Decent Essays

The podcast Serial, hosted by Sarah Koenig, follows the riveting murder mystery of Hae Min Lee, a well-loved senior at Woodlawn High School. The prime suspect was her ex-boyfriend, Adnan Syed, with whom she had broken up prior to her death. Throughout the series, Koenig analyzes court transcripts and investigates the prosecution’s evidence in order to determine whether or not Syed’s incarceration was justified. Due to the absence of physical evidence and numerous inconsistencies in the state’s allegations, Adnan Syed is innocent in the murder of his ex-girlfriend, Hae Min Lee. Syed did things that most teens do. He smoked, lied, and engaged in other activities that his parents would disapprove of. The prosecution used this information to …show more content…

This was one of the first cases in the county to utilize cell records and inspect cell tower pings. The prosecution uses the information to suggest a timeline of events that most likely occurred that day; however, there is a disclaimer on the cover sheet of the AT&T records notes that the data gathered by incoming calls is unreliable. The defense failed to acknowledge this. Another key piece that was used alongside the cell records was Jay’s depositions. Jay was a drug dealer who had graduated some years before Syed. He came forward pleading as an accessory to Lee’s murder. Problems arose when the defense took note of the variations in Jay’s interviews with police. In a 2015 interview with The Intercept regarding Jay’s fluctuating story, state prosecutor, Kevin Urick claims, “People can very seldom tell the same story the same way twice. If they did, I’d be very suspicious of it because that would look like it was rehearsed.” However the irregularities in Jay’s story are too significant to simply brush off. Jay mentions that he and Adnan go to Patapsco State Park to smoke. This detail was never included in Jay’s other interviews, and is never brought up during trial. This version of the story offsets the proposed timeline. During the trial, Syed’s attorney, Christina Guttierez, addresses the fact that the prosecution had provided Jay with an attorney, which was unprecedented in a court case. It is possible that Urick and

Get Access