preview

Pollution and Environment Essay - Man Has No Responsibility to the Environment

Better Essays

Man Has No Responsibility to the Environment

Since the 1960s, questions concerning environmental ethics have loomed large in the public awareness. At the heart of all of these questions is one single issue that has caused confusion among many people involved in this controversy. There has been much debate on this issue, but little has been fruitful, and this can in part be blamed on the fact that the debate is of a particularly low quality. Much of it has been of the name-calling, conclusion-with-no-justification-spewing variety. The central problem with the environmental debate is that the debaters engaged in attempting to provide solutions to these issues do not agree on the humanity's place in the natural order. Rather than …show more content…

Just like other living things, we have strong drives to mate, to produce young, and to find situations that are "safe." All living beings strive to gain control over their environments.

Other animals, which also have basic drives, are most certainly not concerned with environmental ethics. If an organism is introduced into a new ecosystem, it will strive to fulfill these drives for control and reproduction until the ecosystem evolves a new balance. Some organisms do practice population regulation -- but, in doing so, the organism is doing something which is good for the species. It is highly doubtful, for example, that lemmings plunge over the side of a cliff to be nice and not overburden the food producers in the ecosystem. Rather, when a large proportion of lemmings commit suicide, they leave several members of the population behind to begin again this cycle of overpopulation and cataclysmic self-destruction.

Since no one argues that other animals should be bound by ethical considerations, the question becomes: What is it that makes humans different from other animals? And the answer, of course, is that, although the animals that we designate as "human" have, frequently, many differences from those animals which we designate as "non-human," there is not one thing that they share in common which separates "humans" from other animals and provides us with any sort of moral obligation toward "the environment."

Answering

Get Access