All around the world, human lives are being lost due to preventable diseases whose spread could be slowed through immunization. As such, I am proud to, as Pro, support legislation that would make immunization mandatory.
Model
For this debate, “this house” refers to first world nations such as the United States or Canada, where the infrastructure necessary for creating and distributing vaccines is already present and well-maintained; this means that issues such as the economical burden vaccination places on health care systems will not be discussed in much detail. I believe that all people should be legally obligated to be vaccinated, except for those who can have severe allergic reactions to vaccines. The possible consequences of refusing vaccination include fines and forced vaccination.
Signpost
For this round, I will be making three points: firstly, that vaccines are safe and effective, and secondly, that the government has a responsibility to protect its citizens—even if it may result in less opportunities for people to choose personally, and finally, that vaccination should not be a choice since herd immunity means that one’s decision not to vaccinate can affect others as well.
Safety and effectiveness of vaccines
Scientific research has shown vaccines to be safe and effective. As this debate has limited
…show more content…
In a 1998 study involving children published by the New England Journal of Medicine showed that the intranasal flu vaccine increased antibodies in the bodies of its recipients, and decreased the likelihood of flu. Results showed that the vaccine was more effective than placebo. (1) A 2012 study published in the Journal of Infectious Diseases showed that flu vaccines “was associated with a three-quarters reduction in the risk of life-threatening influenza illness in children.” (2)For older adults, however, flu vaccines may have a lower efficacy—but they still prevent 61.2% of flu hospitalizations.
There is no doubt that vaccination has been one of the greatest successes of public health programs in the 20th century. Vaccinations have eradicated naturally occurring smallpox, and have substantially reduced morbidity and mortality from infectious diseases that previously ravaged the population, such as polio and measles. Despite the successes, there has been a history of “anti-vaccinationists” in the U.S., who among other challenges, argued compulsory vaccination was an infringement upon personal liberty and their right to choice (1, 2). In fact, it took a Supreme Court decision to ultimately assert whether a state mandating vaccination infringed upon the U.S. Constitution.
Public health is controversial in many cases because it requires balancing individual freedom and the greater good of society. Vaccinations can eliminate communicable diseases, but can be difficult to impose vaccinations upon individuals because of their sense of liberty. In this debate, there are those that support mandatory vaccinations to promote the health and wellbeing of the entire population and those that oppose mandatory vaccinations to protect themselves from any potential side effects. This controversy must be handled delicately by public health workers.
Vaccines are a very useful and important piece of technology in modern medicine. Without the aid of vaccines, countless numbers of people would become infected with diseases that can potentially be fatal, epidemics would occur on a massive scale, and death tolls would be much higher. Granted, vaccinations aren’t perfect and there have been cases in the past in which vaccinations have had serious side effects and in some instances, even death. Major medical organizations however, such as the FDA, AMA, and WHO, have stated that vaccinations are safe and that adverse effects are rare. Even so, there are some who believe vaccinations are not to be trusted and choose to not have themselves or their children injected with them despite risks. There is much controversy over vaccinations and their side effects, and one of the major topics discussed is whether or not schools should allow children who have not been vaccinated. All of the heated debate over vaccination has led to one essential question being asked, “Should the government enforce mandatory vaccinations,” not
Over the years there has been a lot of controversy regarding vaccinations and their effectiveness. Recently, people have argued whether or not vaccinations are necessary. Matthew F. Daley’s and Jason M. Glanz' article “Straight Talk about Vaccination” goes in to explanation of an adverse event that ended in multiple deaths that occurred because people were not getting vaccinated. Also, in today’s society more and more parents are opting to post-pone their children's vaccinations, even completely refusing vaccinations due to officials sending out false information about vaccination through social media. Getting vaccinated is better than going about unvaccinated by and as evidence Straight Talk about Vaccination. In this article all appeals of logos,pathos,ethos,and kairos are evident.
There has been an ample amount of dispute over the morality, effectiveness and the safety of vaccination ever since the original smallpox vaccine over two centuries ago. Parents, teachers, children and health care specialists all have a vital stake in this debate. Parents believe they should have the right to make the decision on whether or not to vaccinate their children. While health care officials disagree, claiming that by not vaccinating, all children will be susceptible to the vaccine-preventable diseases. Megan Heimer discusses the risk of vaccinating a child and that it should not be mandatory in her article, “The Hate Debate”. Although Megan Heimer writes a relatively convincing argument, I strongly disagree. I believe that vaccination should be mandatory. It is a parents’ responsibility to protect our children and future generations from these preventable diseases.
Vaccination has been a long-established and adopted practice in the U.S. since its inception. Having been required for certain school districts since the early 1800’s, many have wondered if the government should play a role in this. Vaccines are safe and effective, eradicating numerous diseases which were once prominent. However, they are neither perfectly safe nor perfectly effective. Government enforced vaccines disregard modern medical ethics as well. Nevertheless, they should be widely encouraged.
A world without vaccinated children would be a very bad and very dangerous world. Not vaccinating children can be very dangerous and could even cause the death of an innocent child, whose parent made the decision to not vaccinate their child due to lack of education about vaccines. This has been a very controversial issue in the united states for a very long time and it is times for a change on the way parents think about vaccines and people need to work together to get vaccines to become a normal thing parents do for their children. Vaccines should be mandatory in the United States because it would insure the health of children in the U.S. , vaccines do more good than they do harm, and vaccines protect other people from contracting
Vaccines have been shown to be the most effective way to eliminate or reduce the prevalence of life-threatening diseases within our population (Lantos, Jackson and Harrison, 2012). However, there has been a growing concern with outbreaks of these diseases showing up repeatedly throughout the last few years. This has caused a sense of worry among parents with children. I believe that vaccinations should be mandatory and that no one should be exempt based on personal belief if the disease is deadly enough to cause harm. I will explain my argument to justify mandatory vaccines through the benefit for the common good of society, the harm principle and its welfare baseline.
In a world that is continuously evolving, we’ve come a long way from epidemic and rampant diseases. From the Black Plague to the swine flu scare in 2009, diseases have always existed but luckily vaccines were created to mitigate or even eradicate them. A vaccine is a product that produces immunity from a disease and can be administered through needle injections, by mouth, or by aerosol. The first vaccines came out around the late 18th century to early 19th century with the invention of smallpox vaccines. Unfortunately, not everyone agrees with vaccines, much less mandating all vaccine. Whether or not the whole population should be vaccinated has sparked recent debates; some people have legitimate reasons and fears of vaccines while others are
The government should mandate vaccinations, and although it would sacrifice the liberty and choice for public health it would keep the well-being and health of everyone much more safe and away from the risk of disease. Most people agree that vaccinations should be mandated because of how being vaccinated keeps people safer in public environments since being vaccinated helps stop diseases from being spread, as proven by science, but people who do not agree with vaccination mandation most of the time will not even look at the signs pointing to the fact that mandating vaccinations could be extremely beneficial. “We simply do not know how to make people who are against vaccinations come around to trust and accept the science behind them"
There have been 9028 deaths that could have been prevented with vaccines from June 3, 2007 to July 18, 2015. (Anti-Vaccine Body Count) A child shouldn’t suffer because of parents choosing not to vaccinate children. Vaccines should be mandatory for all citizens in order to keep the general public healthy. There have been falsified reports made leading to panicked parents not vaccinating their children causing disease outbreaks such as Measles. The children involved became infected with a disease because of their parents’ choice and through no fault of their own. No one should die from an easily preventable disease, especially if the vaccine for it is easily accessible. Vaccines should be made mandatory to prevent the deaths of kids who didn’t choose to go un-vaccinated.
As you and I both know the CDC has been able to provide vaccines to prevent diseases such as measles, mumps, whooping cough, and many other viruses that effect the United States each year. A vaccine is used to enable your immune system to create disease-fighting antibodies. Getting vaccinations are important not only because they protect you from diseases, but they can also prevent you from spreading diseases to other people. Through vaccination children can develop immunity without suffering from the actual diseases that the vaccines prevent. Ask yourself “What if we stop vaccinating?” Obviously, the diseases would make a comeback. Before long we would see epidemics of diseases that are nearly under control, and therefore if the CDC
An American scientist at Cornell University once said, “Advances in medicine and agriculture have saved vastly more lives than have been lost in all the wars in history” (Sagan). Vaccination, a result of the technological prosperity, had been practiced for centuries to counteract, if not stop, all kinds of diseases. It had been a way of preventing major illnesses to spread from one person to another. Vaccines are inactivated or attenuated viruses that helps the body develop a strong immunity against detrimental diseases. It helps strengthens the population’s health and prevent them from having illnesses. Despite these advantageous benefits of vaccination, there is still an immense and great ongoing debate as to whether vaccinations should be optional or mandatory. Although others believe that vaccines should not be non-obligatory, it is safer and preeminent to conclude that they should be required. It is justified to have mandatory vaccinations for they prevent extremely lethal illnesses, create a life-long immunity and protection against all kinds of diseases, do not possess major life-threatening side effects, and preclude possible epidemics.
Not all students returning to school this month will be up to date on their vaccinations and a new paper in Gender&Society by Jennifer Reich,a professor of Sociology from the University of Colorado Denver, correlates it to the class privilege of their mothers.
[Thesis] Vaccines alone have been accredited to the eradication of disease and for some people that is not good enough, they would rather believe stories than fact. I propose that a new nationwide law be passed, a law to make vaccinations mandatory for all children, with the only exemption being religious, and severe medical reasons.