preview

Reno V. Aclu

Good Essays

The parties involved were Janet Reno, attorney general (1993-2001) of the United States, which also makes her the head of the U.S. Department of Justice, she is the first woman in this position#, and the American Civil Liberty Union (ACLU). The ACLU is a nonpartisan organization dedicated to preserve and extend the basic rights of the U.S. constitution.# b. The problem began when President Clinton signed the Telecommunications Reform Bill into law on February 8,1996. A group of people, led by the ACLU went to court and succeeded in temporarily stopping the implementation of the bill's "decency provisions." After this district court decision, Janet Reno appealed directly to the Supreme Court. The most controversial parts of the …show more content…

It said that this Act was in a way creating "adult zones" on the internet and that was constitutional based on the decision in Renton v. Playtime theatres Inc. CDA was not trying to ban "indecent" material, just to separate it, so that minors could not access such material. However, the zoning laws could not be applied to the internet because it is not a physical place, therefore a person who posts information cannot be certain that it will not reach minors, since there is no way to prove if a person is a minor when they are online. # d. One would assume that a conservative would approve of the CDA because it would really limit exposure of sexually explicit material to minors, and that liberals would not because they are not as socially conservative. Justice Rehnquist is a conservative and is known for sticking to these values. In this decision, he stayed in part with his ideology because he was only part dissenting. Justice Scalia is a conservative who consistently votes in favor of free speech, which is what he did in this case. Justice Kennedy and Thomas are conservative. O'Connor is known for treating each case differently and trying to find a practical solution. Justice Stevens is known for being a "wildcard" he does not stick to a particular ideology. Justice Souter does not always vote with a particular ideology. Justice Ginsburg and Breyer are both liberals. With these ideologies taken into consideration, it does not seem that the justices voted

Get Access