preview

Robert Van Gulik

Good Essays

Through a thrilling murder mystery blended with action, romance, and suspense, Robert van Gulik captures the fascinating culture of Tang China and its political and social life. Van Gulik’s novel incorporates diverse characters with varying roles in Tang society, allowing for a more expansive view of the social expectations and perspectives of people of all social classes. ALTHOUGH THE WILLOW PATTERN IS A FICTIONAL NOVEL PUBLISHED IN THE 20TH CENTURY, IT INCORPORATES MANY PRACTICES AND HISTORICAL FACTORS FOUND IN TANG CHINA, INCLUDING A LEGAL SYSTEM, A BLEND OF BUDDHISM, TAOISM, AND CONFUCIANISM, AS WELL AS SOCIAL EXPECTATIONS OF PEASANT AND ELITE WOMEN THAT MAKES THE NOVEL A PLAUSIBLE REPRESENTATION OF THE TANG DYNASTY. Elements of the legal …show more content…

Additionally, criminals would face a trial led by a magistrate, who employed both physical and verbal evidence to convict the defendant. In his novel, Van Gulik incorporates both a court trial and system of codified laws similar to that used in the Tang Dynasty, which is evident when Judge Dee convicts Madame Mei and Hoo Pen of the murder of Mei Liang. As Judge Dee serves as the magistrate of the military tribunal in place of the Emergency Governor of the Imperial capital, he uses the evidence he gathered from Madame Mei’s home, the site of the murder, and the statements of Madame Mei, Doctor Lew, and Hoo Pen to determine how the murder was committed. The judge also abides by martial law to convict Doctor Lew and Hoo Pen – for example, he convicts Hoo Pen of a capital charge for the murder of Mr. Mei, stating that the court “sentences the accused Hoo Pen to death by decapitation” as per the law system used in Tang China (van Gulik, 168). Van Gulik utilizes the “murder mystery” genre to accurately portray the legal system used during the Tang Dynasty. Tang society heavily ritualized standards for female behavior under Confucian social norms, and …show more content…

However, the popular beliefs of the Tang Dynasty that shaped the people’s social expectations and behavior as depicted in The Willow Pattern is arguably the most effective at making the novel a viable representation of the time period. This factor is not only prevalent in the characters’ actions, but it also has a prominent effect on the development of the novel’s plot. Mrs. Mei, the murderer of her husband Mr. Mei and the cause of the central conflict of the novel, reveals to have committed this crime out of selfish desires during her trial under Judge Dee – she explains that her lust for power and an escape from the constraints of the patriarchal system, actions that go against the ideal Confucian woman’s expectation of obedience and reverence for her husband, was her motive for her crime. Mrs. Mei, although sentenced by the court to death, dies of illness, representing how her defiance from her social expectations results in her own downfall. On the other hand, Bluewhite and Coral, although they also commit murder, are spared of punishment by Judge Dee due to their endeavor of honoring their parents and protecting their family. The twins exhibit the traits of ideal Confucian daughters, and in turn, are “rewarded” for upholding their social duties.

Get Access