McCurdy, Spradley ad Shandy (2005) state that when performing ethnographies, we should choose accessible microculture. Since it was difficult for Rubenstein to find informants who were available, I believe he should have changed his microculture to study. It would be extremely difficult to study relationships that are forged at the station when you only are interviewing one person. Had his original three, willing informants been available, he would have been able to perform a much better study.
It would have also been beneficial to be able to use informants of various ranks such as the Chief, the Captain, the Lieutenant, the Recruit or Candidate, as well as the general members of the team. Being able to observe how they interact with those
…show more content…
More often these days, you hear of females participating in roles that previously were male oriented. Do you believe that life would be different in the fire station if there was a female on the squad or engine companies? Do you think that it would be more difficult to build a relationship with a female firefighter than with a male firefighter (or vice versa if interviewing a female firefighter)? Why?
3. There have been several popular movies and television shows that portray the lives of firefighters. Some of these such as Backdraft (Howard and Lewis, 1991), Ladder 49 (Russell and Silver, 2004) and Chicago Fire (Wolf, 2012) present life as a career firefighter. However, in the United States, close to seventy percent are volunteer firefighters (National Fire Protection Association, 2014, p. iii). What differences do you see between career firefighters and volunteer firefighters?
Berg and Lune (2012) suggest using the Spiraling Research Approach. Had Rubenstein used this approach, he would have included some literature review as part of his study and the naïve reality that I believe existed within his study may have been eliminated or at least minimized due to the background information he may have discovered prior to the data collection portion of the study. As it stands, we do not know the questions that Rubenstein asked John, his informant. Rubenstein shares seven excerpts of his interviews with us, but we do not know in what context these remarks were made. That is,
To better understand the background of the contrasting views, we must look at how the fire service has developed around
in an attempt to increase the diversity the fire service have introduced methods such as appointing an equality and diversity officer to the community who is there to discuss and talk to women and ethnic minority groups about the career opportunities they would encounter if they joined the fire service. The service has introduced a 10 year strategy which has a goal of improving the way the workers treat each other across all parts of the Service but also the effectiveness of the relationship that they have with the public. The strategy has 5 different areas which the service aims to work on to improve diversity.The first is Leadership and promoting inclusion where they want individuals to ‘undertake their role in promoting equality and diversity and ensure any practice or procedure they have responsibility for is effectively equality impact assessed’. The second is accountability which will include the workers making ‘evidence available to the public annually on improvements to service delivery and employment practice, including progress against the employment targets through its website’. The third area is Effective service delivery and community engagement. This aims to involve community and voluntary groups in policy development including members of minority ethnic, religious, disabled, lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender communities, men and women, and all age groups more within the work of the fire
The main difference over all is that if the research was not done the way Raybeck had originally conducted it, the book would have been a lot more formal with its scientific reasoning’s.
After the almost fatal accident my grand mom was in, this passion grew stronger of helping others. The fact that firefighters help people when they need help the most makes the job all the more awesome. Joining the fire department gives me the power to help others in extreme circumstances and gives me the potential power to have a positive impact in some one’s life.
Female police officers have been saddled with a stigma ever since they were allowed to join the force with male officers. Female police officers performance and ability to do their job and perform well is often questioned because they are women. Female officers are not given the same respect as male officers because of their gender; however, they bring different skills and assets to the profession that male officers do not. Female officers are less likely to use force or become aggressive because they have better communication skills and empathize. However, female officers will resort to using aggressive behaviors or force when necessary. Superior officers and male patrol officers feel that women are only on the force because it is a matter of social integration and an HR requirement. They feel that this is a man’s profession, and women have no business trying to be a part of it.
Both are very great and skilled at what they do, but you gotta hand it to volunteer firefighters as they lay their lives on the table to save someone they barely know and don’t even get paid a lot. Volunteers catch crap for not being a career they are given the privilege to run blue cautionary lights to alert people to move over and slow down. A volunteer firefighter does not have to respond a career firefighter does. A volunteer firefighter gets out of bed and uses there own relax time to go help a complete stranger never knowing the scene they are walking
Employment opportunities for the female police officer are large. Women will be recruited for many jobs in the field to expand the pool of potential sworn officer. It should be a goal off policing to recruit females so they can be recognized on the streets, making it more of a position that women not in the field of police work an option as a career choice. Allen (1973) States, about women police officers, “any question of the value of their contribution to the solution of police problems has long ago been relegated to the limbo of things proved and taken completely for granted.” (p.213) The status of women police officers has grown since the beginning of women in the law enforcement field. As many might think that it is an overwhelmingly large amount, it is still generally a small amount. “Women were 37% of the labor force in 1979, 45% by 1992 Women hold less than 5% of all senior management jobs across the US. Women's representation in
Among police, there are stark differences between male and female officers. Cara E. Rabe-Hemp researched these sex differences by conducting a series of interviews with policewomen. These interviews reveal how policewomen cope with the seemingly impossible task to find a balance between feminine values that they were raised to uphold and masculine values that their male-dominated field demands. According to the individual perspective, employees’ performance is more shaped by their unique personal experiences as opposed to standardized formal training (Britt 185). Since neither police officers’ formal training nor their subculture reduce or eliminate the differences between policemen and policewomen, sex differences have a much more significant
Qualitative research methods are used to examine the perceptions of women police regarding their career opportunities and trajectories, and their experiences with regard to the culture, practices, and policies of policing. Purposive sampling was used to identify and recruit a representative number of policewomen as study participants. Subjects completed surveys and participated in in-depth interviews. Data was analyzed through the use of constant comparative procedures, with member checks and interrater reliability scores obtained to ensure trustworthiness of the data.
Even in today's world of political correctness, there is still a very large gender bias when it comes to certain things, such as Emergency Medical Services (EMS). The number of men in the field is much higher than the number of women. Women, for the most part, are looked at as not being as capable of performing what is required of an Emergency Medical Technician (EMT) or a Paramedic as men are. EMTs and Paramedics are required to make split second, possibly life saving decisions, lift large amounts of weight, and work long hours in all conditions. Since most women are physically smaller than most men are, they are viewed as not being strong enough to lift patients or equipment in many situations.
The constant presence with his troops was the most significant act of building cohesive teams through mutual trust. In Fact, “how he found the time and energy to be constantly with his frontline troops and still direct the overall activities of the division was a mystery.” 1 Interacting with your subordinates shows that you care. A leader that trains with his subordinates also earns credibility. How Soldiers trust, weights leader’s sound judgment for leading troops and accomplishing missions, regardless complexity.
When it comes to race within law enforcement, male police officers still question whether women can handle the dangerous situations and physical confrontations that officers may be confronted with, while it is shown that most police women have easily met the expectations of their superiors. Indeed, studies have found that, in general, male and female officers perform in similar ways. In addition, research has found that most citizens have positive things to say about the work of police women (Worden,
Firefighters are ordinary, standard people who put themselves in dangerous situations to save faultless people. For instance, firefighters are rescuers, who are trained to extinguish uncontrolled fires. This
Throughout the many years that we have been the human race there have been fires. When there is a fire there has to be someone to put it out, that’s where a firefighter comes in. A firefighter is person that not only puts out a fire but makes sure that the people that may be in a fire get out safely and securely. Is there a problem with a women becoming a firefighter, many people would seem to believe so but others say why not. Being a woman or a man should not take away from the fact that they are both trying to save lives. So it should not matter whether or not a woman is a firefighter or is trying to become one.
I think you are right: the 18 year old seemed more excited about being a firefighter because she has not gone through the experiences the other two women have. It would be safe to assume the two older women in the film were as excited as she is when they were first training to become fire fighters. However I do believe in some jobs, women are trying and fighting to a certain degree, successfully to overcome their obstacles. For example, we hear more and more women holding executive positions on different companies, when it was mainly dominated by male. However that does not mean this particular women had the same advantages, or her road to that position has been the same as her male counterpart holding a similar position, even