Saving Private Ryan Essay

Good Essays

Saving Private Ryan
Saving Private Ryan portrays the experiences of the mysterious captain John Miller and his army ranger Squad. The story accurately depicts what could have happened to a comparable unit mission shown had actually existed. No Saving Private Ryan character ever existed. Furthermore, it is unlikely that Saving Private Ryan’s mission ever would have been ordered. The mission shown is improbable because United States army sole survivor policy “is applicable only in peacetime.” (Sergeant Rod Powers, ret.). Regardless the movie shows the chaos that American soldiers may very well have encountered while marching through Normandy subsequent to D-day. All the weapons and equipment Saving Private Ryan used were used were …show more content…

Despite the attention to detail Saving Private Ryan still has some inaccuracies. For instance, the film shows only American soldiers. D-Day was an allied operation that involved many countries yet only Americans are shown. The Portsmouth museum reports that the “United Kingdom, Canada, the US, Australia, Belgium, Czechoslovakia, France, Greece, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, and Poland.” (D-day museum Portsmouth) all participated in the D-day landings. The chances for an American unit walking through Normandy immediately following D-Day and not meeting any allies of another nationality are highly unlikely. The mission would not likely have happened; the current sole survivor policy does not provide rescue missions, the high mortality rate making those missions uneconomic.. The policy today simply allows a soldier who has suffered the loss of a family member a resignation from the service if the given service member is having a crisis that is tough luck. However, the Chief of Staff who ordered this mission can pretty much do what he wants so the mission could have happened. This movie is not a documentary, it simply captures the experiences possible WWII soldier experiences. Using fake people helps the director explore the values and characteristics of the soldiers under stressful conditions. By avoiding basing this story on real people Spielberg is not limited by facts. Saving private Ryan’s inaccuracies are not overwhelming, they do not

Get Access