EDUC 512 Issue 1.5 Should Public Schooling be Redefined? Issue 2.6 Are Local School Boards Obsolete?
Marla Layton
What is the role of public schools? Who should be governing public schools? This paper will address each side of these educational issues as well as offer a position statement and an action plan.
Issue 1.5 Should Public Schooling be Redefined?
Fredrick Hess- Pro Position
• A public school’s mission is to prepare students to be productive citizens (Koonce, 2015).
• Public schools routinely require private money from families for tuition and extracurricular activities, which makes them similar to private schools (Koonce, 2015).
• Pubic schools rarely hold to serving public purposes such as teaching about laws and the constitution and teach their own belief systems surrounding social issues such as “tolerance and diversity” (Koonce, 2015, p. 61). Hess objects to teaching about these ideals since they are too open to interpretation (Koonce, 2015).
Linda Nathan, Ray Bacchetti & Evans Clinchy- Con Position
• Linda Nathan states public school systems are open to the general public whereas private schools may select their students (Koonce, 2015).
• Ray Bacchetti believes public schools support conversations with differing viewpoints that further a student’s support for an ideal or challenges it (Koonce, 2015).
• Evans Clinchy contends that it is the role of public schools to remain solidly connected to the “will of the citizens of our local communities” (Koonce, 2015,
Educational policies researcher Joel Spring (1996) discussed many arguments and historical background about various education topics found in the United States. For example, Spring tells us about the historical development of the Common Schools movement and the underlying groups—such as workingmen and political parties—that influenced the movement. In addition, Spring points out some of the implications the movement had on religious, ethnic, and multicultural groups. One particular idea that caught my attention was from the chapter entitled, “The Ideology and Politics of the Common School.” Indeed, my entire conceptual understanding of K-12 education had been predicated on the idea that high schools were part of the original conception of public
For a long time now our school systems have been pretty straight forward. It was always private schools versus public schools. Usually families with more money are able to send their children to private schools, and if not, children attended public schools.
“Official from Milwaukee school and local policy groups, where public school choice has been an option, confirmed what most observers have assumed: that having options with in the public school system is intensely popular with parents” (Van Dunk, 2003) Some people do not believe there can be such a thing as public school choice. For it to be actual ‘school choice’ and in order for it to succeed it has to include private schools. (Jeynes, 2000) These are just a few facts and some issues that are controversial around the Public School Choice option.
Proponents for public funding of nonpublic schools believe parents should have freedom of choice in the education of their children at the public expense because all students deserve a quality education as outlined in
Public Schools: Receive funding from local, state, and government entities. Charter and Magnet are also considered public schools. They must admit all students within their zoning. There are some schools that will except students outside their zone if there is room. For example, a Burbank High School student may prefer the dance company or football team at Burroughs High School, which is across town. They can apply and if there is room, they may attend there.
This rhetoric, which suggests that public education is failing, is not only misleading, it is dangerous because it may erode public confidence in the very institutions on which our capacity for a democratic response depends.Criticism of public education has continued unabated since the publication of A Nation At Risk in 1983. Stimulated in large part by new international economic realities, by a domestic economy based on traditional production models, and by changing domestic demographics, the critics have sought solutions to these challenging problems by turning to schools and educators. The data cited by critics of public schools were accepted at face value until the late 1980's. However, since
When it comes to the American public education, we are faced with several difficulties that effects everyone. It all depends on how a person views the education concerns. Everyone wants to solve America’s education issues and it’s essential that we focus on the right things to move forward and offer better opportunities. It’s important that we first focus on how public education impacts all people. It can’t just be what people believe to be true but how it has actually affected their learning and life.
Specific purpose: After reading my paper, my audience will understand the importance of the public education system in America, as well as the areas in which it could improve to have a more meaningful, lasting effect on the students.
Private schools, unlike public schools, do not receive tax revenues. Therefore, they are not required to follow the same regulations and bureaucratic processes that govern state-funded schools, which sometimes hinder the public system. According to Great Schools, “this allows many private schools to be highly specialized, offering differentiated learning, advanced curriculum, or programs geared toward specific religious beliefs.” While I was at Lakewood the classroom size ranged from twenty-four to thirty students for each grade and the smaller rooms allowed more one-on-one time with the teacher. The students were encouraged to reach out to the teacher when there was confusion over a topic discussed in class. Also if the student was not progressing or making an initiative to study, the teacher would contact the parent/parents to create a plan that would help the learner. During my elementary years, the private school also taught about manners, respect and Christian values. So when I moved to a different town, I was forced to go to a public school in Ada. I learned very soon that the two school systems have extremely different methods of teaching. The teachers were sometimes less willing to help the student succeed and most did not communicate well with my parents when I was having difficulty adjusting to a new school. Another problem I noticed was the teachers did not try
This book is about a group of parents and community members from Kentucky who became frustrated with the representatives of their state. This group felt a lack of urgency on the part of the politicians to improve the quality of education. They formed a non-profit group that consisted of 30 community members in 1980 and was formalized in 1983. The committee was led by Edward F. Prichard and now recognized as the Prichard Committee. The diligent work of this group paved the way for the Kentucky Education Reform Act in 1990.
Private and public intuitions have been in the industry for many of years. Many people discuss wither private schools or public schools are subsequently better investment to how students adapt and learn over years. These topics have been around for centuries. By looking back at articles and information I can find the information needed to examine how private schools and public schools differ but in addition have similarities.
Many people are biased either towards public schools or private schools. According to a 2009 poll, one out of four parents are currently considering to switch their child’s education from private to public or vice versa due to the economy (GreatSchools Staff, 2015). There are several advantages and disadvantages of private school as compared to public school.
A private school’s curriculum can be chosen by the individual school charter instead of the state, while public schools have to follow state education guidelines strictly. Although these guidelines can be limiting, they make sure students get the basic education they
The debate on public versus private schools has attracted numerous arguments on their merits and demerits over the years. Although both have their benefits, none is considered better than the other particularly in the US. The government funds public schools, and thus parents do not have to pay for the tuition. On the other hand, in private schools parents fund their activities through tuition payment. As such, parents who have no income constraint usually prefer private schools. Based on a recent report, approximately 10% of the student populations across the US are enrolled in private schools (Ingersoll, Merrill & Stuckey, 2014). Some of the reasons explaining why some parents prefer to take their children to private school include religion, desire for a more student- focused learning environment characterized by small class size among others. It is within this context that the paper will explore the benefits and drawbacks of both public and private schools in the US. The paper is in support of public education, and thus it will strive to make a case in favor of public schools.
Public and private schools both have the general program of math, english, reading, writing, science, history and physical education. Public schools give you more classes to further your career in whatever you desire to do. For example, most public schools offer music, art, foreign languages, technology, and career education programs. Many states keep track on the success of the students learning through standardized testing. The states determine what the minimum achievement level must be in order for a student to receive credit for a certain course. Private schools are known to have a harder academic reputation. Often, their grading scale is more difficult. Public schools offer some college prep classes, while private schools usually have college prep as their main focus. Generally, class size differs between public schools and private schools. Public are free, so most people send their children there because many can’t afford private school tuition. This causes public schools to have larger class size. With public, you don’t have as much one on one time as you can get at private schools. For public