Hi everyone,
My reaction to the article was very much in line with what Ellen and Russell have already stated. The topic sounded very interesting, but the article felt very emotional, almost an opinion piece about how being a doctor isn't very fun.
I found the term 'love-relationship' slightly strange, and it left me wondering whether the author was referring to some type of serious long-term relationship, or whether they had in mind the ability to sexualize, or make sexual advances to, any or all of their patients. For me, clarifying this is important, as I am sure the latter would receive stronger reactions than the former.
If the author has in mind a serious relationship with someone who they initially met as a patient, then it doesn't seem that the doctor and patient in question face very serious challenges to overcome the professional boundaries that doctors currently abide by. That is, if there is a mutual interest from both parties, the patient can opt to change doctors, or wait until their current treatment is completed before proceeding with a romantic and sexual relationship.
…show more content…
Patients go to doctors to get objective consultations. People want to feel comfortable, particularly when a doctor visit involved bearing parts of one's body. They don't want the possibility of being approached sexually by their treating physician. Changing the professional guidelines of doctor patient relationships could have negative impacts on patients, and leave many with aversive feelings towards having
There are many social factors that can impact on the Doctor Patient relationships everything from race to gender. To break it down and find five, I started with Doctors personal views he is under pressure to be ethical when he may not entirely be accepting of a person’s beliefs or sexuality. For instance a doctor may be homophobic and have a patient attend surgery asking for advice on practicing safe sex and being HIV aware. Following on from this may be a patients confidence in doctors due to race for example a person who has racist issues would not feel comfortable attending a foreign doctors surgery. To find a third I would have to say gender being a female I tend to talk easier to a female doctor, which persists problems as my female doctor only works three days a week so I put off going to see the male doctor so therefore remain ill longer. My fourth factor is age, as the doctor could be old and the patient adolescent. This would impact on different generations living different lifestyles and changing societies. “Adolescence is indeed a tempestuous period”, (Thorne, B & Lambers.1998). Finally I find language barriers a major social factor as if you can’t understand what your doctor is saying to you it has complications in treatment and there is not always a translator available.
There are many ways of forming a relationship and gaining the trust and respect of the patient and I had to work out the different things that make a good therapeutic relationship. According to Hinchliff et al (2003) there are a number of important elements that make a good therapeutic relationship, but it is important to make clear that a therapeutic relationship is a formal relationship between a medical professional and patient. The Nursing and Midwifery Council (2008) maintains that at all times nursing staff must maintain appropriate professional boundaries in the relationships they have with patients and clients.
From the moment they began their journey at Harvard Medical School, their entire life became medicine and medical related topics. Constantly studying for school, exams, board tests, and for their future, stress was no stranger. “Stress refers to physical and psychological responses to overwhelming stimuli… Burnout is actually a combination of factors” (page 115, DePru). Stress leads to burnout, and many medical professionals face both roadblocks in their careers. In Doctors’ Diaries the students stress did not subside when the graduated, it only increased. Once they were placed in their intern positions, adjusting to their new jobs brought on more stress than some could handle. The doctors had to learn to be modify their lives and their expectations in order to stay on top. In example, Jane learns to be a positive influence for her patient’s in her inner-city hospital for she fears that she might be the only flicker of light they see for awhile. Jay Bonner and Tom Tater display the greatest burnout and stress. Tom cannot seem to find his place within the hospital and even doubts his own abilities. Tom is a hard worker and he is more driven than his peers. When Tom is fired from his ER job, he realizes how burnt out he is with the system, not the
When patients visit the sexual health clinics for check-ups or to collect results, it can be a little embarrassing to
Discussion how “words of comfort” encapsulated the books take on medicine, I feel that these words are showing us how in medicine being a caring and sympathetic health care provider is important. (Verghese, 2009) In the book relationships with patients is shown to be as important as the care they are providing. Knowing how much technology and medicine has advanced in the last years I feel that no matter how good the scientific side of it is there has to be a relationship with the health care providers and patients. It is proven that a positive relationship helps a patient recover faster. Relationships can help in many ways just having someone to talk to, give feedback, and encouragement are all way relationships are able to benefit and speed up recovery. (Brainline, 2015)
The story of Love Medicine revolves around a central character, June Kashpaw, and the many threads of relationships surrounding her, both near the time of her death, and in what has gone on before. The novel is an exploration of a family web that June was a key component of. Her character is a pivot point
However, as much as he wanted to lose himself in the warmth of Tom’s embrace and savor the sweetness of his soft, tender kisses, Doctor Levine’s words echoed loudly in his mind. Whilst he understood Tom’s need for affection, he respected Levine’s qualifications as a doctor and he knew he needed to push aside his own wants and needs, and do what was right for the damaged man standing before him. Therefore, he made a decision that he hoped would be agreeable for all
It deals with a topic that is very important for many in the medical field and for anthropologist, but I also feel it would be an important for anyone else as it shows something few people see or experience. Although there are a few hiccups that may affect certain readers, I feel like those can be overlooked as they are not major issues. In the end I feel that aside from doing what it was intended; it did something more as I feel that it showed us that our medical system despite being one of the most advanced in the world is distant from the people which makes it much less effective for certain people like it was with the Lia and her
Honorable doctors do their best to uphold the Hippocratic oath by being kind to their patients and doing their best to connect. At Harvard, they are now teaching how to connect and bond with patients through Patient-Doctor classes to create a more effective and comforting hospital experience. I know when I go to the hospital, I enjoy when doctors and nurses talk to me about my life and theirs. That bond that is created helps build a trust that this doctor cares and wants what's best for those that they treat; when things go wrong, it also opens up the ability to comfort one another. Building relationships between doctors and patients change the dynamics so that it ends up being doctor
In the excerpt of Love Medicine, Lipsha Morrissey tries so desperately to repair his grandparents’ broken marriage. He is an extraordinary, dynamic character both with pros and cons. It is evident he has his family’s best interest at heart; however, him caring so much leads to negligence with his “love medicine.” Because Lipsha is in love with the idea of love, he tries relentlessly, albeit carelessly, to get his grandparents back together. Lipsha is aware he possesses special powers.
Molly O’neill’s article "A surgeon war on breast cancer" tell a story about a gay mother woman doctor who works as a director of the U.C.L.A. program and fighting the battle of cancer. Dr. Love is a clever surgeon. she makes the patients feel more comfortable with her, the kindness Doctor who try to make conversations with them. this article show us that she was loyal with her job and with her patients. one of her patient asked her before the surgery to make sure that she will be fine and take good care of her, she was very confident when she said " I will take good care of you." Furthermore, this confident woman have done what she can trying to find solutions to those who has suffered form this disease and how this disease grow between their
Throughout the story you find yourself experiencing the thoughts and feelings of the doctor. The writer describes the characters and the environment as the doctor is seeing them. You get a clear understanding of the emotions the doctor is going through as he struggles to examine the child. Upon arriving he is cautious as he senses the fear and tension from the parents. He feigns annoyance at the way the mother speaks about him to the child and he grows increasingly angry and frustrated as the young girl fights and resists the examination he knows he must
I have always been intrigued with the functioning of biological life from a young age. My admiration for human life sciences is the main purpose for me to choose the medical field profession. Medicine is my number one career choice. I appreciate challenges especially those towards a gratifying cliché and despite medicine being an intense vocation, it may be coveting; emphasized by the doctors I have discussed with at an individual level. Noting the doctors in the clinic was enrapturing and I could observe the field from a more composite side than only the high school biology course. Throughout my experience I extended my certainty and conversational skills through dialogue with patients and doctors. Albeit I enjoyed that period it was at times amazingly heart rendering. I was able to talk and relate with numerous patients to build up their spirits. All my experience and education has made me more determined to fulfil my aspiration to become a doctor.
Dual relationships occur when a practitioner is in a professional role with a client as well as taking on another role outside the clinic with the client. The professional needs to assess the risk in the relationship and whether both the practitioner and the client can differentiate between a boundary crossing and a boundary violation. In rural area’s a dual relationship may be unavoidable, the article discuses that the practitioner may have been chosen because of the prior relationship, and that some form of prior relationship may even be a prerequisite for the development of trust and respect in a small community. However, Zur also writes about the “Slippery Slope Effect” in which that all boundary crossings eventually lead to sexual relationships and boundary violations. The author then notes that the slippery slope effect is an unreasonable link and adds that when thinking of crossing a boundary the professional needs to consider the welfare of the client and benefits to treatments, whilst avoiding harm or exploitation and to respect the client’s autonomy (Zur 2004, pp27-32).
The doctor-patient relationship always has been and will remain an essential basis of care, in which high quality information is gathered and procedures are made as well as provided. This relationship is a critical foundation to medical ethics that all doctors should attempt to follow and live by. Patients must also have confidence in their physicians to trust the solutions and work around created to counter act certain illnesses and disease. Doctor-patient relationships can directly be observed in both the stories and poems of Dr. William Carlos Williams as well as in the clinical tales of Dr. Oliver Sacks. Both of these doctors have very similar and diverse relationships with multiple patients