Rodney Stark and Roger Finke’s Acts of Faith explores the idea of religion acting like an economy, and, more specifically, religion responding to competition in the same way that markets do. In the background of this idea of a religious economy is the overarching question of why America has higher rates of religious participation. Using data from a variety of European countries in conjunction with data gathered in the United States, Stark and Finke found that decreased religious pluralism, as a result either of a country’s history or government regulations, indeed led to lower rates of religious participation, up to a certain point (a “ceiling”, to keep with the economic language). That is to say, “Catholics will be more active the less Catholic their community.” A notable exception to this theory, however, is Mormonism. …show more content…
Another religion that is seemingly immune to the market theory at first glance is Catholicism, according to Stark and Finke. The authors contend, however, that although Catholics in Western Europe are more active than one would expect given the homogenous religious makeup of those countries, this deviation from the theory can be explained away by the fact that Catholic clergy rely on “voluntary oblations of the people”. All in all, Starke and Finke’s Acts of Faith presents a compelling narrative of religion acting according to the rules of a market
The core of research on religion at present is of no doubt touching Max Weber’s ideas on economic traditionalism. Weber in Solimano (2012: 42) talked about “the importance of religion, especially the Protestant ethic” in economic life. By venturing into the field of sociology of religion, Weber further succeeded in arousing many scholars’ interest in the study of different religions in the contemporary world. Agbikimi (2014: 30) notes that “Weber’s theory of religion has to do with the interaction between society and religion”. This essay, discusses interia Webber’s prominent writings on religion which are in fact related to economic traditionalism and the study of religion. The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism has been widely discussed in this essay. Berger (2010: 3) argued that it indicates the continued relevance of Weber’s analysis regarding the correlation of the religion and economic development.
In Protestant culture, the emerging philosophy was that “trade is one thing and religion is another”. The concept of economic secularism, which meant removing the church from economic activities, represented the amount of change which occured since medieval
After reading through many articles about many different religious groups in “America’s Communal Utopias”, I have observed many different communities grow using both similar and different ways to find their own success. Two societies in particular, that struck me in their techniques to survive were, the Shakers and the Mormons. Both of these religious groups today are still successful. Both groups used methods of economics, gender roles, and their relationship to the outside world to find their own success in the religious community.
This paper explores the different views of religion between three sociologist writers, Karl Marx, Max Weber, and Emile Durkheim. It discusses a few different religions and the percent of Indiana that is religious. It will go into examples about how religion has developed over time and how Christians all have one big thing in common. Throughout the paper, it will explain how Christians are trying to share the word of God and make their community a better place.
To some extent it could be argued that the U.S is a less secularized country than Australia. However, with research as evidence it can be argued that the U.S is to the same extent as secularized as Australia. Both countries prohibit the religions from having any influence on the state by having a true separation. With the number of people believing in a religion constantly changing, it is evident that it has become stronger in the public sphere and that there is a strong connection between education and welfare levels of a country and it’s religious outlook.
It can be characterised as a wholesale commodification of religion, that is the selling-off of religious buildings, ideas and claims to authenticity in service to individual/ corporate profit and the promotion of a particular worldview and mode of life, namely corporate capitalism” (15). Carrette and King are making an important observation that religion has become a good that can be sold and traded through the idea that spirituality is a certain way of living. The “Prosperity Gospel” falls into this spirituality trap that Carrette and King address. The “ideas and claims” are seen when prosperity preachers tell their congregations that monetary donations will lead to an increase in personal wealth, and to better health. Meanwhile the “promotion of a particular worldview and mode of life” is apparent when prosperity preachers teach their followers that money and property are essential in God’s plan for them, and it is a sign of their spirituality when they prosper. In addition, the “selling-off of religious buildings” can be found in the numerous mega-churches and multi-million dollar mansions that prosperity preachers inhabit. The wealth of these places sell the idea that fancy buildings are signs of a healthy spiritual lifestyle being lived in God’s favor. Overall,
The Axial Age (for purposes of this paper, and in our reading) span from 800 BC until 600 AD, and saw the rise and fall of empires, the invention of coinage and markets, and the birth of countless philosophical and religious schools of thought. From studying this innovative and tumultuous time period, one may come to several conclusions on how material gain and spiritual thought may be closely linked. Here, the pursuit of ‘profit’ became the pursuit of ‘social good’; the lines between civic and marketable gain became blurred, forever changing the attitudes of peasants and the rich alike. The Axial Age was a crucial period in our history in which leaders learned how best to manipulate their populace, philosophical thought took root in the rational ratios of the cosmos, and market economy became not only a medium in which to acquire that which one needs to survive, but the bedrock upon which our society is built. I plan to support the idea that coinage and the rise of religion during the Axial Age is supported by explaining the following concepts from our reading: that the calculation of debts, market economics, and a fundamentally different system of trading allowed a space for new philosophical thought to emerge, that the pursuit of profit became synonymous with the pursuit of personal betterment, that governments realized it was crucial to suppress the total economic gains of its citizens, and that religion was in part founded to placate the poor, listless masses.
Theologian Kathryn Tanner examines the power and influence a global economy provides through a theological perspective in her book; Economics of Grace. Tanner breaks apart her theories into 3 sections that include drawing connections to, and contrasting the economic principles and the values of Christianity. Throughout her book, Tanner re-iterates her own theory of the relationship that regards to an “Economy of Grace”. God offers goods to his children and expects them to share what they receive, therefore; based off of the non-competitive nature of the dual physical and spiritual world, the economy should be noncompetitive to every degree possible to resemble God’s graces.
Church and religion in America have been a major impact on economic and social roles. In addition it has played a huge role in the makeup and creation of communities. Many people use church and religion to help them cope with death, loss, and difficulties in life. Three major religions in the United States have played a major role they are Protestants, Catholics, and Jews. But in recent years, although still religious, America has seen a decline in religious practices. In addition with politics playing a key role in the US we have seen people’s attitudes change. Republicans are probably just as religious as in years based but not as much with other political affiliations. American religion has also seen more of a tolerance or acceptance towards
Karl Marx, a German philosopher, once said, “Religion is the opium of the people.” During the medieval ages, religion drove the daily lives of the people. People used the Catholic religion as a way to justify their living conditions in order to ease their suffering. However, the upper class used religion to their advantage as it enabled them to deceit the lower class into giving them money. This created a disparity between the two classes. In The Book of Margery Kempe by Margery Kempe, the Catholic ideology blinded society from the corrupt socioeconomic system between the bourgeoisie clergy and the proletariat.
Are new religions and religious practices swamping the old? According to Chaves, the general consensus in America is that religious participation and membership have decreased. As the General Social Survey and other studies show, contrary to popular belief, the rate has not decreased but it also has certainly not increased. The result, then, is that the rate has remained relatively consistent. In order to properly interpret the following data it is important to note that, in this type of study, it is difficult to obtain precise and accurate figures because it is not empirical data.
The current paper aims to (1) define what it means, outside of a quantitative or sociological viewpoint, to be a religious minority, and (2) suggest religious minority status is not damning (or non-positive)
Max Weber’s The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism is a comprehensive treatise on the cultural origins of modern capitalism. Through observations of occupational statistics by country, Weber uncovers a surprising phenomenon: individuals from a higher socioeconomic status, namely owners of capital, are largely Protestant (Weber [1905] 2011: p. 67). Consequently, his intent is to establish a relationship between religion and the modern economy, which is centered on work and material success. In this book, Weber traces the ethos of capitalism to ascetic Protestantism. Defined by Kalberg (2011a), the “spirit of capitalism” is a reference to the “methodical orientation toward profit and competition, work ‘as an absolute end in itself,’
During times when a country is economically growing, people are less likely to engage with religious affiliates or engage religious practices/traditions. Jochen Hirschile proposes that during economic growth, people do the opposite of what Max Weber says about building traits and values (Secularization Of Consciousness’). Economic Growth actually causes people to have a decline in traits and values, which ultimately concludes that there is a decrease in religious practices among people. To support Hirschile, Benjamin Friedman also discusses how economic growth can cause people to become consequently less moral (The Moral Consequences). On the other hand, people tend to become more religious during times of economic distress and uncertainty. Simon Metcalfe and Reginald Harris conducted a study on how the
Sometimes the two have conflicts with each other, but the American culture has found room for both to be present. American secularism derived from the strength of religion, not from its weakness. McClay makes one more observations about the relationship of religion and secularism in American life and that is that the most successful movements for social reform in American history are likely to have had a respectful relationship to the country’s religious heritage, if not being driven by it.6 Avoiding church does not excuse Americans from marking the birth of Jesus, however. Most of us have no choice, but to stay home from work or school and if you complain about this evident exception to the separation between church and state, you must be a miser with no heart for tradition. Christmas has been a federal holiday for 146 years. The idea of Protestant civil religion sounds strange in a country that prides itself on secularism and religious tolerance. However, America’s religious free market has never been entirely free. The founding fathers prized freedom of conscience, but they did not intend to purge society of Protestant influence.7 In contrast to the secularism in the United States, secularism in France is the polar opposite of that in the