preview

The Bechdel Test

Better Essays

Films have been shown in public for over a century (Earlycinema), and in that time they have become a common and treasured pastime for children and adults. No matter what is going on in the world, film can provide a source of escape and give the viewer a chance to step into another world (McCracken, 2010). However, even in another world it is important for the viewer to see traces of their own world to make a connection to the film. One way that viewers can relate to a fictional world is through relatable characters such as characters of their own race, gender or class. Unfortunately this is not always the case, and oppressed groups tend to be underrepresented in film and media in general.
In relation to feminism, which is the movement concerned …show more content…

One flaw with the test is that it does not take intersectionality into account, meaning that it can quantitatively measure the representation of women, but it cannot draw comparisons between the number of women of a certain race, sexual identity or orientation, class, or other components of intersectionality (Hobbs & Rice, 2012, page 39). Another flaw is that it does not necessarily consider the value female characters are adding to the film, or if they are just in filler or stick roles for the sake of inclusion, not to add valuable diversity (Scheiner-Fisher & Russell, 2012). Therefore, a movie may pass the Bechdel Test without being feminist in nature (Felperin, 2013). According to Scheiner-Fisher & Russell (2012), the test “does not ask if a film is feminist, only if there is a ‘female presence”. As Derr (2013) points out, the question of whether or not a film is feminist is complex as a feminist film may mean different things to different …show more content…

One famous and notable example of children’s films are those produced by the beloved Walt Disney Company, a company which exerts “a powerful influence on children’s media…contributing to a new “girlhood” that is largely defined by gender and consumption of related messages and products” (England, Descartes & Collier-Meek, 2011). England, Descartes and Collier-Meek (2011) also claim that Disney films are highly accessible to children and that they are a popular choice of both children and their parents. While some may see Disney films as wholesome and family-friendly, Zarranz (2007) sees something deeper—he sees past the innocent nature of the films to a deeper level, a level of “power relations and adult sexuality”. Zarranz (2007) discusses various ways that popular animated Disney films are harmful to women, from setting dangerous body-image ideals to patriarchal social structures in The Little Mermaid, to hyper-sexualisation and colonization themes in Pocahontas, to expected housekeeping duties and need to be rescued in Cinderella. These themes do nothing more than perpetuate overused and damaging

Get Access