preview

The Effects Of Contributions And Consequences Of Immulation

Decent Essays

Summary
In this study by Gadagkar et al. (2016) they studied the mechanisms behind dopaminergic neurons and auditory feedback. More specifically, they tested to see if dopamine encodes error in performance evaluation tasks, such as singing (Gadagkar et al. 2016). In previous studies, they found that these birds learn to sing through error-related negativity in ventral tegmental area (VTA) neurons (Gadagkar et al., 2016).
Methods
To test their hypothesis, they first recorded VTA neurons of zebra finches while listening to distorted or undistorted songs (Gadagkar et al., 2016). They divided this experiment into two distorted conditions –one where the distorted feedback was one of the bird’s own, and another synthesized sound (Gadagkar et …show more content…

Analysis
This article by Gadagkar et al. (2016) is important to the literature as it introduces a marriage between two concepts of classical ethology and comparative psychology – biological underpinnings and learned behaviour. Bird song clearly has a biological basis, as shown in the similar activation of VTAerror neurons to reward prediction (Gadagkar et al., 2016). However, it also has a learning component, as shown through the performance evaluation mechanisms (Gadagkar et al., 2016). Thus, it is essential in showing that there is no one basis to behaviour.
Tinbergen’s Four Questions Tinbergen came up with four essential questions to help comparative psychologists and ethologists study animal behaviours. He discovered that both fields were essentially studying the same concepts, but were studying different causes. These questions were later defined as proximate and ultimate questions. The ultimate questions concerned the long-term evolution of the genes of an organism, such as questions of function or evolution. Meanwhile, proximate questions were concerned with the causes of short-term behaviour, such as immediate causation and development. In the Gadagkar et al. (2016) study, the researchers were concerned with the immediate causation, or the encoding of performance error in singing birds. Their question, consistent with immediate causation as it dealt with one behavior in the short-term and the mechanisms behind

Get Access