preview

The Work Of The Heart : Young Women And Emotion

Better Essays

Martha Tomhave Blauvelt, in her book The Work of the Heart: Young Women and Emotion, 1780-1830, proclaims that “we need more useful conceptual tools to understand history as men and women actually experienced it.”i Indeed, Blauvelt 's book is an attempt to forge these tools through a meticulous examination of the diaries of young women in America at the turn of the nineteenth century in the hopes of understanding how these women constructed and expressed their emotions. She employs the work of two sociologists as the theoretical apparatuses of the book: first, Arlie Russell Hochschild 's idea of emotion as work, something which requires an active effort to adhere to the rules dictating how one is supposed to feel in a given situation.ii …show more content…

The organization of the book explores this private rehearsal and public performance in different realms of young women 's lives: Chapter 1 is on social class; Chapter 2, education in a private boarding school; Chapter 3, courtship; Chapter 4, anger; Chapter 5, the reconstruction of emotion in marriage and religion. Note that at no point in the book does Blauvelt give an explicit biographical sketch of any of her women, but rather only elucidates the lives of her subjects within specific contexts. As such, Blauvelt refers to Elizabeth Cranch 's erstwhile fiance early in the book, and only names him and his eventual death much later; similarly, Abigail May 's early death is not mentioned until halfway through the book!vi These problems are not problems with Blauvelt 's scholarship, but rather with the sources themselves: diaries are performances of a different kind, and “ego-documents” demonstrate an image of others far more than the diarist. In the first three chapters, there is an explicit tension between what women wrote in their diaries and how they actually interacted with society writ large. Sarah Connell 's diary speaks of how her “Papa was low-spirited,

Get Access