Matt Clendening Eng 1301 6th 1/24/10 Klepper The Worker Next Door
In the essay “The Worker Next Door” written by Dr.Chris Chiswick, the author addresses the illegal immigrant problem in America, and gives several questionable reasons how if the flow of illegal immigrants were deterred, jobs would still be filled, and life would go on as usual, or even better. Dr.Chiswick wrote a not too convincing essay, having many places where he could have improved or even left out certain parts of his essay that would have made this writing better, and more realistic to his audience. I spotted a couple areas where the author went on a tangent of barely related areas to illegal immigration. Along with that, it doesn’t really seem like he tried to
…show more content…
Have you noticed how in this very essay, there doesn’t seem to be a nice flow between topics, and that things may at times, seem fairly irrelevant to the subject at hand? This is how i felt while reading “The Worker Next Door”. Chiswicks organization is flawed, jumping from claim to claim
The various approaches to coaching and how much authority parents had depending on how involved they were. Transitions, such as closers or openers most of the paragraphs cause readers to be lost in the in the wrong areas and a quick switch of the setting hurt the initial and long-term meaning of the essay.
A recent study shows that many immigrants are taking jobs that normal Americans do not take. These jobs are low paying and dangerous, but they are vital for our everyday lifestyle. Without them, life would be less convenient if it were not for them. These immigrants are an important part of the American lifestyle, and many authors write books and essays to support or deny this claim. Two specific essays, A Quilt of A Country and The Immigrant Contribution, talks about how without immigrants, the United States would be a completely different place. These essays use different dictions, or word choices, to express their thoughts on how the immigrants contributed to our society. Anna Quindlen, the
Overall, the essay seemed to lack flow as a result of a noticeable absence of transition words. The essay had bad syntax. Each paragraph seemed to be scenario after scenario and each sentence seemed to be idea after idea. For example, in the first paragraph, the list consisted of multiple sentences, instead of just one sentence with commas. “But they are few: Being mistaken for a wheat field by a cloud of locusts. Being buried alive”...“Interviews from film festivals.”, this seemed like an awful way to list ideas. In addition, the fourth paragraph of the essay was made up of only 2 sentences, one
The first essay in chapter twenty four is “Five Myths about Immigration” by David Cole. He begins his essay by exploiting a group from the mid-nineteenth century called the “Know-Nothings” who blamed all of America’s problems on immigrants. Cole then goes on to acknowledge what he believes are the five myths about immigration. These myths include: America is being overrun with immigrants, Immigrants take jobs from U.S. citizens, Immigrants are a drain on society’s resources, Aliens refuse to assimilate and are depriving us of our cultural and political unity, and lastly noncitizen immigrants are not entitled to constitutional rights. Cole gives reasons why these five myths are not true and by using facts he makes his argument more believable.
“We must end welfare state subsidies for illegal immigrants. Some illegal immigrants—certainly not all—receive housing subsidies, food stamps, free medical care, and other forms of welfare.” In this statement by Ron Paul, a Texas congressman, it is obvious that this subject needs a serious look into modifying our current guidelines. He also states, “Illegal immigrants place a tremendous strain on social entitlement programs. Under a proposed totalization agreement with Mexico, millions of illegal immigrants will qualify for Social Security and other programs-programs that already threaten financial ruin for America in the coming decades.”(1) They
One of the important problems that the author raised is the legal status of the illegal immigrants and their depressed living conditions. The legal status and living conditions are interconnected because in order to rent a decent apartment you need to prove that you are legally present in USA with thorough documentation which the illegal farm workers will not have and hence these poor workers were miserably compromised to live in pits, trenches and under trees. The author describes that the poor farm workers were very bad in shape and are constantly at the mercy of variable adversities like natural disasters and bad weather. If there is a storm they get wet all night and the only way they can dry up is to wait for the morning sunlight. Also illegal immigrants keep move place to place to find a job and look for shelter to stay because of their constant move they can 't afford to have permanent structured home at one
Cole is able to successfully inform his readers due to his effective knowledge on studies regarding immigration, statistics, snippets of information from other sources, and quotes while staying on topic with every paragraph. For example, in Cole’s third myth, “Immigrants are a drain on society’s resources,” Cole says, “As a 1994 Urban Institute report concludes, “Immigrants generate significantly more in taxes paid than they cost in services received.”” (Cole 186). Furthermore, Cole’s fourth myth includes, “Aliens refuse to assimilate, and are depriving us of our cultural political unity,” He then follows this with a statement made by a Supreme Court Justice. Reading this essay, you are able to gather that Cole is in fact a writer who stays professional, and honest within his writing, completely leaving out any biased or negative
In 2012, the immigrant born population was around 40.7 million people in the United States. Even though we initially came to this land as immigrants from mainly the European countries, we are still very protective of our country. Americans have this greediness when it comes to having our own land and not sharing it. Remembering back to when Americans first came to this region of the world, we kicked out the true natives and made this land our own for our safekeeping. Hundreds of years later, we still have the same mentality of keeping The United States away from others who were not there in the first place to take it over. Jones-Correa and Mendoza both address the issue of letting in immigrants and whether it could benefit our society or not. They
Throughout the history of the United States, immigration has become a part of our country’s issue which bean centuries ago. The issue of undocumented immigrates has become the primary focus in this year’s election. Undocumented immigrants are foreign born people who lack a right to be in the United States, having either entered without inspection or stayed beyond the expiration date of a visa or other status. Undocumented immigrants are seen as double edged sword. When people move into an area, legally or not, it can also mean that there will be more consumers and potential workers, but it can also mean fewer jobs for locals. Large numbers of immigrants and their families cannot help but have a significant impact on the cultural, political,
I think one aspect of the book I found most troubling is the working conditions some people around the world are subjected to. Even today these poor working conditions continue with the factory fires the author speaks about at the epilogue. I think many of us in the United States take what we have for granted. The authors reference to the poor working conditions around the
Furthermore, the proper outlook here is one where we acknowledge that we have these potentially undocumented individuals living and working in the United States, and they aren’t going be be removed all at once, so while these individuals are here, why not give them the necessary tools and programs to allow them to function as productive members of society without restriction. In many of our readings, we’ve witnessed legislation that has also played a role in the deterred success of illegal immigrants and those here legally. Legislation such as barring immigrants from being able to acquire driving license or being able to receive healthcare benefits are laws that not only hurt the immigrant population, but also the American population.
Illegal immigration is an on-going issue, which is of much importance in the United States today. It has been overlooked for many years, however it has reached a point where it can no longer be ignored. Most of the illegal immigrants, 54% to be exact, come through the Mexican border. (Hayes 5) Since the early 1980’s, the number of illegal Mexican immigrants has risen at an incredible rate, causing the United States government to take action to create an even-handed solution that would be in the interest of both the illegal Mexicans and the citizens of the United States. This, however, has proven to be very difficult since it is still an issue today. The argument is that the
Johnson has a sub header, Student Voice, in each chapter that gives a real-life example of what she is trying to get across, where she included “La Migra”, where Esperanza Borboa reflects on her work experience at a garment factory in California and with farm workers in Washington state. She observed the exploitation of undocumented immigrants, including employers making anonymous calls for immigration raids before pay day and even refusing to pay those who returned. Hanson gave his point of view from all different aspects-the entry-level labor, ethnic chauvinism, legal immigrants, the law, Mexico, poverty, moral racketeering, and politics. For example, the Political reason describes how a politician would handle immigration and the effect that it would have in their career if they were to communicate something and it comes out as offensive (158). Therefore, illegal immigration has an immense impact in America because various people have different views about the
I am writing in response to the article ‘Endless waves of Illegal Immigrants floods Rio Grande Valley” by Jana Winter for FOX NEWS on July 14, 2015. In this article, it mainly focuses its attention on the negative aspects of illegal immigrants and makes the reader believe that immigrants are the problem. The article, makes illegal immigrates seem like they are all criminals and villains. On top of that, this articles doe’s little to no explaining on the reasons for why immigrants to come to the United States. Having grandparents and parents who were illegal, I know some of the reasons and motives behind the decision to migrate to the United States such as escaping poverty, providing a better future for their kids, and the opportunity to pursue the American dream. If these points were added into this article, Americans would be more sympathetic to the situation of millions of immigrants and make movements to get legislation passed that would offer citizenship, work visa, and green cards to illegal immigrants.
10). On the other hand, in the document “Overview- Illegal Immigration,” states that “immigrants take on hard and dangerous jobs that citizens will not do... [so] immigrants’ labor and entrepreneurship help to revitalize American industries and create more jobs than they take”( par. 10). Immigrants don’t actually take jobs from American citizens, because many come to create their own businesses which create more job opportunities. Jacob G. Hornberger also said that “traditionally immigrants are among the hardest working and most energetic people in a society, which brings positive vitality and energy”(par20). People should be paid by their efforts, not by where their from. People also “believe that all illegal immigrants are, by definition, lawbreakers, and thus are more likely to commit other crimes as well. Others link immigration with the illegal drug trade”(par. 9), as stated in the document, “Overview Illegal Immigrants,”. Although immigrants are thought to be the bad guys, immigrant rights activist Anne Carr argues that “immigrants commit crimes as often as American citizens, a fact true of both legal and illegal immigrants” (par.8). In the document, Immigration is not increasing crime rates they inform us that, there have been dozens of national