preview

The law reform process has been effective to a certain extent in achieving just outcomes in regards

Decent Essays

The law reform process has been effective to a certain extent in achieving just outcomes in regards to native title. This can be seen through both the Eddie Mabo case [1992] and the Yorta Yorta case [2002] as although the cases had been concluded with final decisions, there were still measures that could have been taken, and areas where it could have been improved to achieve a just outcome.
MABO V QUEENSLAND (NO.2) [1992] HCA 23
In 1992, the doctrine of terra nullius was overruled by the High Court in the case Mabo v Queensland (No.2) [1992] HCA 23. After recognising that the Meriam people of Murray Island in the Torres Straits were native title landholders of their traditional land, the court also held that native title existed for all …show more content…

YORTA YORTA V QUEENSLAND
The Yorta Yorta people were one of the first Indigenous groups to make a native title claim in Australia, in February 1994. The Yorta Yorta people claimed native title to an area of land and waters in the Northern Victoria and Southern New South Wales. However, the High Court rejected the appeal, and it was concluded by the judge that the Yorta Yorta people had ceased to occupy their traditional lands with relation to their traditional laws and customs, and that the period of time in between had washed away any evidence and acknowledgement of the practise of their traditional laws and customs. In order for Indigenous people to prove their Native Title rights, they must prove that they have had an uninterrupted connection with the land and the practise of the traditional laws and customs has been maintained since time of colonization. This rule disregards the effects of colonization; that indigenous people have been forcibly removed from their homes, cultures being forcibly altered which all results in an adaption to the new environment and way of life. Therefore, the required burden of proof is quite discriminatory, making it increasingly difficult for Indigenous people to prove

Get Access