preview

Transgender Issues In The Military

Good Essays

Thinking it would help to overcome his desire to become a woman, Dwayne Villanueva joined the U.S. Army at 17. Even while serving in what he described as a hyper masculine environment, those feelings did not go away (Tilghman). Dwayne, who identifies as a woman, has since legally changed her name to Laila. Although Laila has been accepted as female, both culturally and personally, the Army still considers her male. Laila is just of one of the estimated 15,000 transgender individuals currently serving in our Armed Forces whose life will be impacted when the policy changes go into effect which will lift the ban allowing transgender individuals to serve openly in the US Armed Forces. This much anticipated policy change comes after the Don’t …show more content…

Specifically, the applicability and rating structure of the military fitness standards and where transgender troops would fall in line on the scale, which is currently different for male and female service members. This issue is being reviewed by top Pentagon officials and the details are yet to be released. Allyson Robinson, a West Point graduate and policy director for SPARTA, an advocacy group for LGBT service members, suggests that the military could follow the National College Athletic Association’s (NCAA) lead regarding regulations relating to transgender college athletes. Current rules utilized by the NCAA require transgender women to undergo a 12-month hormone therapy before competing. Said rules further prohibit transgender men from competing after having started hormone therapy (Tilghman). Thus, should the DOD follow the NCAA’s lead, the concern over whether transgender individuals would have an unfair advantage in the fitness standards would be minimized, if not, …show more content…

To alleviate this concern, a senior official with the DOD announced that the working group will also develop a plan and program to train the troops, ensuring a smooth transition (Rosenberg). The 6-month timeline for lifting the ban will provide the DOD with time to review and make changes to the policy. As with the 2011 repeal of the DADT policy, the lesson learned was that the gradual approach to lifting the ban resulted in the successful transition and implementation of the new policy

Get Access