preview

Utilitarianism, And Virtue Ethical Dilemmas

Good Essays

I. Evaluate the choices faced by Steve Lewis, Peter Adario, and Eduord Sakiz (in Badaracco’s article) from the standpoints of the generalizability, utilitarian, and virtue ethics tests.

The manner Steve Lewis’ handled the situation he encounters from the standpoints of generalization was appropriate. Hooker (2011) said that we act for a reason, and all of his reasons have rationale, which Steve act on without compromising his core beliefs. He was not satisfied just being a member of the team, but he wants contributes to the team to maintain his self-respect and earn his advancement instead of hand it to him. Even though he was unable to perform his part of the presentation, nonetheless, he gains the respect of his peers and maintain his …show more content…

His decisions need to study and ought to emulate by CEOs when facing similar problem. He clearly passes the generalization test because every action he took has a rationale. Obviously, his reasons were morally just. He wants to make sure his corporate receives profits from the sales of the contraceptive drug RU-486, while protecting his employees. He passes the utilitarian test because his action resulted in the maximization of utility not only for his organization, but everyone that are associated with the RU-486. He wasn’t sure if the RU-486 drug was going to be marketable, because the noise from the anti-abortion groups was palpable (Badaracco Jr, 1998, pp. 122-123). Nevertheless, the tactic that he used to trick other organizations to force them to sell the RU-486 drug was extraordinary. His decision to suspense operations even though the France government already approved the sales of the drug, which forces organizations that support the RU-486 drug to rallied around him was not only shrewd, but also insightful. More importantly, he was able to secure his future, keep business interest group happy, the board belief in his leadership, but also support his fiduciary to his shareholders. More importantly, he protected jobs and the security of his employees, while serving the populations that needs the contraceptive drugs. …show more content…

It is difficult to determine reasons behind organization decisions because businesses were established to make profits. In today’s global market, organization cannot survive if they stay on the straight and narrow lane. Executives are continuing to respond to the global market by moving around chess pieces on a chessboard to stay ahead of the game. It’s hard to ignore what corporations are about especially when it is painted all over their website. While some of these characters seem to be moral, however integrity and virtue were sacrifices to fill their pockets as in the case of Wal-Mart bribery cover-up in Mexico. Wal-Mart chose profits over integrity and virtue (David, 2012). In 2015, Starbucks decided to remove all Christian symbols from their holiday cups. While their decision seems to be morally just, however it is impossible to ignore the fact they also benefit from free advisement

Get Access