preview

Vasquez's The War Puzzle

Better Essays

Vasquez illustrates the various working and conceptual definitions of ‘War’ in his book ‘The War Puzzle’. He points out the definition of War given by Hedley Bull according to which ‘War is an organized violence carried on by political units against each other’. If this definition of war is to be taken into account then war by all means involves collective violence and it is simply not synonymous with conflicts because all conflicts may not end in war. Another assumption that is made as pointed out by Vasquez is that the war is an organized violence with 3 characteristics i.e. 1. War is an ordered activity with rules and customs , 2. War is not a random phenomena of violence but which is focused and directed, 3. It is collective and social …show more content…

He acknowledges the fact that in the modern global system realism has shaped the behavior of major states . He has also dealt with the common realist practices that include alliance making, military buildups, balancing of power, and realpolitik tactics . He argues that these practices may be fundamental to the realist beliefs but having said that, these practices do not produce peace and security as the realist would argue , but increased insecurity , coercion, and entanglement in a process that leads the “road to war”. He maintains that each step leads further and further into a trap where the ultimate end is ‘war’. In a situation of threatening security issues the states increase their military power through alliances and military buildup. Military buildup further leads arms race in a tense situation and alliance making may result in polarization of blocs, both of which increase insecurity. Realpolitik tactics are employed in a military disputes between equals and eventually disputes would lead to war. Vasquez has focused on how interactions lead to steps that brings states closer to …show more content…

He has not substantiated his argument with facts as to why certain alliances do not lead to arms race. The United States Institute of Peace has illustrated wide range of events in 20th and 21st century that has led to Peace and not to arms race. It contains events that created global and regional international bodies and other mechanisms for peaceful resolution of disputes and conflicts , major alliances which sought not to end wars but to promote lasting peace, treaties and agreements meant to halt or control the spread and use of weapons, especially weapons of mass destruction etc. Eg: 1)Atlantic Charter ( August 14, 1941), United States president Franklin D Roosevelt and Great Britain Prime minister Winston S. Churchill. 2) Partial Nuclear Test Ban Treaty(August 5,1963), signed in Moscow between the US , the Soviet Union and United Kingdom. The treat prohibits nuclear test and other nuclear explosions in the atmosphere , oceans or space. 3) Paris Treaty (January 27, 1973) ,signed between US , North Vietnam , South Vietnam and Viet Cong , intended to end Vietnam War. There was a Liberal Democratic wave that led most of the alliances to join hands and make

Get Access