preview

Warkentin Chapter Summary

Decent Essays

How does one describe land? What determines how one describes it? Does it matter about what year the chapter is written? In Chapter 12 of Warkentin’s text, he elaborates on the spacial complexities humans had in British Columbia between 1840’s and early 2000’s. Warkentin flows from the Southern British Columbia region to the Central areas of British Columbia then continues observations to the Island-Pacific coast which finishes with the Metropolitan B.C. His expertise of the land is almost overwhelming with descriptions of the Natural features, resources, and settlements within the area expressing tremendous spacial and humanistic details, highlighting the Canadian Pacific Railway (CPR) and the important history between Aboriginals and the settlers of this time. Unlike Warkentin, Bone describes a …show more content…

The descriptions he gives about these keystones in history is enough for me to engage in my own research. This made me question which text is the better to learn from, if a book doesn't create a want for more, is it a good book? In terms of learning, I much preferred the Warkentin chapter as it influenced me to dig deeper into the history of topics. 

 What intrigues me about both chapters is their different takes on what the geography of B.C. should represent. The Bone articles highlight an economic opportunity in the mining, and extractions of resources, while seemingly bypassing the history of how British Columbians have gotten to that point. There is a lack of concern for indigenous population and other small communities in particularly the northern regions which should be addressed. Bone does a great job of keeping his text simple and effective for easy reading to catch main points, in my opinion this is where Warkentin has struggled. The detail Warkentin illustrates in his text is profound yet cumbersome at times. Warkentin’s knowledge of the land and how humans have managed to integrate themselves among it to begin the extraction of the materials which

Get Access