preview

What Are The Characteristics Of Advisor Using Theory

Decent Essays

Characteristics of Advisor Using Theory Some of the theories I tend to rely on when working with my students are Kneflekamp & Widick’s (1999) developmental instruction model, Schlossberg’s (1989) mattering and marginality theory, Réndon’s (1994) validation theory, and Stanford’s (1966) challenge and support theory (as cited in Patton, Renn, Guido, & Quaye, 2016). When considering the four variables of challenge and support mentioned in Knefelkamp & Widick’s (1999) theory, I used the structure and diversity components to help Carolyn consider other career possibilities besides business, while explaining the value behind the liberal arts curriculum the college has established. This ties in with the experiential learning component, which I …show more content…

Finally, in contrast to Schlossberg’s (1989) theory, Stanford’s (1966) challenge and support model addressed the dream, design, deliver, and don’t settle phases of appreciative advising, since I not only challenged Carolyn to think about her social and academic goals, but also encouraged her to take advantage of her required coursework, as well as the number of on-campus resources available to her. While I find that the aforementioned theories are the ones I use most often in my work with students, I believe that Baxter-Magolda’s (1992) self-authorship theory gave me a better understanding of why Carolyn was so rash to make different assumptions about her professor, academic ability, and coursework. Carolyn was typical of many traditional first-year students in that they tend to view knowledge as certain. However, as Carolyn progresses through her college career, it will be important for me to continue to challenge her ways of knowing, similar to what I did during our advising session.
Recommendations
Although I found my advising session with Carolyn to go well, I believe there is more I could do in order to make our future advising appointments more meaningful. One observation I noticed was that although I was focused on listening to what Carolyn had to say, I had sat very still, which could have led Carolyn to be unsure of what I was thinking. I

Get Access