preview

What Is The Defensive Argument For The Existence Of Animals

Satisfactory Essays

Miranda Salazar
Livoni
Capstone, Period 1
10 January 2016
Draft of Three Claims

Previously throughout mankind, the sacred idea of each human being belonging to a soul has been a huge argument for viewing other creatures as inferior. It was popular belief that animals did not contain this holy entity that would entitle them to better treatment from humanity. Many people believed that “As human beings were above animals in this hierarchy they were entitled to use animals in any way they wanted” (Animal Rights). This idea is seen as outdated and as secularism is becoming more prominent throughout society, “This argument is no longer regarded as useful, because the idea of the soul is very controversial and unclear, even among religious people” (Animal Rights). This leaves many people skeptical about any beings having a soul, since it is scientifically impossible to prove the existence of souls. Therefore the defensive argument that animals are inferior to human due to supernatural ideology, such as souls, remains at a standstill with modern science. …show more content…

Many people do believe that animal abuse is a problem within society that should be monitored, but granting animal rights is an effective way to diminish physical abuse. In fact, “Animal abuse is one of the most reliable indicators of domestic violence and abuse of children” (Akhtar). Individuals who practice animal abuse are usually associated with similar types of abuse towards other individuals within their life. By passing laws that would grant animals rights and protect them against abuse, America would also be targeting individuals who habit domestic violence towards their wife and

Get Access