preview

What Is The Theme Of Lemon Tree

Better Essays

The film “Lemon Tree” directed by Israeli director Eran Riklis, based on prevent the Israel government from cutting lemon trees of Salma. In the film, Salma represent the voice of the oppressed Palestinian people. Eran Riklis demonstrate gender discrimination on individual level in two societies by showing us the struggle of Salma with Palestine traditions and Mira with her husband, and conflict between Israel and Palestine by symbolize lemon grove as a dispute of between two countries. In history, there was a state of war between Palestine and Israel which started by the foundation of Israel and still continues. It will not be true to talk about peace between two countries. And branch of an olive tree is the symbol of peace. Eran Riklis used …show more content…

She was living there for a long time. Later on, Israel Defense Minister Israel Navon moved next to her grove. Lemon grove was separating their homes and it was also border of Israel and Palestine. The struggle of Salma has started when defense minister decided to uproot lemon trees due to security gap. Salma got a letter from Israel government about the decision of cutting the lemon trees. The letter was written with Hebrew alphabet so she went with the letter to Abu Camal. When she has stepped in to the coffee shop, everyone got quite. In Muslim countries like Palestine, women do not go to coffee shop so Salma acted against traditions. Abu Camal said that “… you are eligible for compensation… but we do not take their money” (Riklis, 2008) which denotes the conflict between these two countries. Salma retained a lawyer to defend her property rights and stop Israel government to cut lemon trees. In spite of Palestinian people, the lawyer, Ziad Daud, supported her on court. According to Tanzer, “The townspeople are so obsessed with insinuations of sin as a widow carries on business with a single man that they fail to see what the outside world is seeing” (Tanzer, 2009) Again, the …show more content…

On interviews he acts like he does not want it but it is necessary for security, but when he talks with his wife, Mira, we can see how hard he wants to get rid of lemon trees. However, Mira does not think like her husband about lemon trees. When she saw the lemon grove, she found it charming. Furthermore, when she heard the plan of cutting trees from her husband, she stared at him and did not say anything. In addition, she said that “there must be another solution.” Which shows that she does not think like defense minister. (Riklis, 2008) Last but not least, she had an interview with Tamar Gera who is a reporter of a newspaper. She talked about the limitlessness of Israel and when Israel Navon saw the interview of newspaper he went crazy. He immediately called Mira, shouted and swore at her. Even he suppressed Mira’s thoughts by blaming newspaper that they distorted what she said. In the movie, Salma and Mira are both oppressed by patriarchal society. Gauntlett states that, in movies women had shown as frightened, weak and victimized. (Gauntlett, 2008, pp 47-50) To start with Salma, she got warned by Abu Camal. He asked about the story that he heard about Salma and the Ziad Daud. Also he warned her about desecrating her late husband’s honor. Afterwards, she got warned as the same way by another guy. On the other hand, Israel Navon was dominant over Mira. As she shown as a weak character,

Get Access